Files
faunosteo/.claude/audits/2026-10-23-rust-r5-upload-verify.md

1.8 KiB

R5.5 verification — round 1 (fresh verifier, Opus; pinned model out of credits) on 2c44506 + a481af5

Contract .claude/tasks/contracts/2026-10-23-rust-r5-upload.md. Persisted by the orchestrator (the verifier is read-only).

VERIFY — VERDICT: ECARTS(4)

  • C1 MET, C2 MET (http://127.0.0.1:80 refused, stricter, pinned), C3 MET, C4 MET
  • C5 NOT-MET: an object over MAX_ASSET_BYTES+1 hits ureq BodyExceedsLimit, mapped to Network and retried; exit 3 instead of a final State (no write happens, safety holds)
  • C6 NOT-MET: ATTEMPTS = 3 is three attempts (two retries), not "retried three times"
  • C7 MET (observation: e2e script puts the key on env argv, security M1)
  • C8 MET, C9 MET, C10 MET
  • C11 NOT-MET: SUPABASE.md exit codes say "2 usage", code exits 1 on usage; exit-1 list misses manifest and handshake. Nit: serde table "zone as array" row unpinned and contradictory wording
  • C12 MET (no frozen path in the diff, documentSha256 27c7383c…2660, import --check 0 differences 6+12)
  • C13 MET with caveat: floor-clarification-check.sh cannot print OK while the declared evals.md:205 STUB stands
  • C14 UNVERIFIABLE by the verifier (check:all ran elsewhere: green 21:21:38, log in the session scratchpad)
  • FLOOR diff-scoped: clean, 4 waived (fixture lines authorised by the R5.4 clarification)
  • Runs: cargo test upload 251/29 suites, curation 241/27, workspace 277 (1 ignored), cli 259; fmt, clippy (5 configs), deny ok; --check RSS 18696 KB

Fixes after round 1 (orchestrator)

C5: final_error maps BodyExceedsLimit to a final State, test an_oversized_object_is_a_final_state_refusal_not_retried. C6: ATTEMPTS = 4 (one try, three retries). C11: SUPABASE.md exit codes and retry wording; RUST.md table row reworded. C13: the script lists the declared line apart (still not requalified) and prints OK. Security M1, L1, L2, L3 fixed (RUST.md §11.16, gate round 1).