12 KiB
Faunosteo functional inventory and roadmap proposal (2026-10-25)
Owner brief « Clôture officielle R0–R5 et reprise de la roadmap produit ». Read-only survey of develop at d6306ff
(four parallel read-only analyses: identity and roles; care data, PDF and sheets; agenda, billing, notifications, public web,
lifecycle; i18n, mobile, accessibility, tests and release inputs). Sources: faunosteo-business-architecture.md,
docs/development/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN.md (27 steps), OPEN_QUESTIONS.md, DOMAIN_MAP.md, docs/design/README.md,
.claude/memory/decisions.md, the code, the 9 migrations, the tests. Proposal only: no decision taken here, no code changed.
Status legend: DONE = implemented and tested end to end from the UI; PARTIAL; PLANNED = in the plan, nothing usable; DECISION = undefined or blocked by an owner decision.
1. Inventory
| Domain | Status | What a user can do today | Evidence | Blocking decisions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Auth and accounts | PARTIAL | sign-up with email confirmation, login, recovery, password change, sign-out, guarded /app (DEV only) |
app/App.tsx, packages/supabase/src/auth.ts (13 failure kinds), config.toml (12-char policy), tests auth.validation 12, guards.RequireAuth 5, LoginRoute 7, SignupRoute 3, authStore 9; no unit test for Forgot/Reset/Callback |
Q7 providers; OAuth (none enabled, Apple paid account); MFA enrolment absent |
| Practitioner profile | DONE (declared scope) | edit personal, professional (practice, title, SIRET format), preferences, locale synced, avatar via the Rust worker | migrations profiles + profiles_professional + files_foundation, pgTAP 002/009/010, AccountRoute 5, AvatarSection 9, e2e avatar 5 (manual) | professional data unverified (Step 9); tabs and "Cabinet et activité" fields of the mockup not built |
| Clients and owners | PLANNED | type an owner name inside a bilan | Owner = { name } in the report; bucket client-files closed |
C4 (global client record), C5, C6, Q6(b), consent texts |
| Animals, multi-species | PARTIAL (model) | pick "Cheval", type name, breed, age inside a bilan | species table with one row; generic sheet model (ordered regions, free codes); DEFAULT_SPECIES_ID = 'equine' |
next species and who authors its sheet; animal record (sex, owner, DOB, id, weight, photo, deceased) = Step 12 |
| Bilans, observations, history | PARTIAL | full editor in the local tool (zones, findings, laterality, vertebrae, severity, comments, conclusion, recommendations, next appointment), draft kept in the tab | reportStore, persistence.ts (sessionStorage), 61 app test files (heldSession 20, reportStore 15, quarantine 13, AnatomyCanvas 11, EditorRoute 9) |
no server storage, no history per animal, no status, no quota: Steps 11 to 14, C11, Q6(a) |
| PDF export, sharing | PARTIAL | export A4 PDF (archive envelope v1), re-import v2/v3/envelope or rescue JSON in the local tool | crates/core/src/pdf, apps/app/src/pdf, pdf.roundtrip 18, pdf.goldens 6, HomeRoute.import 7, core.importWorker 7, n-1.reader 5 |
sharing absent although the sign-up screen promises « partage avec les propriétaires » (fr.ts, auth.brand_note); import for external users gated (BDR-040, PDF_IMPORT_HARDENING §5); Q1 |
| Appointments, calendar | PLANNED | a date or period typed in the bilan, printed in the PDF | nextAppointment (report v3), profiles.timezone |
Steps 19 to 21; calendar library, routing provider, token encryption |
| Booking, payments | PLANNED | nothing | no table, no Stripe code | prices proposed only (€9 / €100 TTC, free = 5 completed reports), cabinet price open, Stripe Tax |
| Reminders, notifications | PLANNED | GoTrue auth mails only (default templates, Mailpit in DEV, no production SMTP) | config.toml [local_smtp], no supabase/templates |
Q7; reminders MVP status contradictory (§34 vs §3.5); consent purposes lack reminder/SMS channel; unsubscribe/STOP not documented |
| Cabinets | PLANNED | free-text practice name only | traces: audit_logs.organization_id, closed logos bucket |
cabinet pricing, seat rules (Steps 10, 11, 23) |
| Teachers, students, verification | PLANNED / DECISION | nothing | closed professional-documents bucket, SIRET check; students/professors owned by no plan step |
C6, legal document list (§5), which step owns education |
| Roles, permissions | PARTIAL | own role badges shown; grant/revoke only by raw RPC or SQL | platform_role (4 values), audited RPCs, pgTAP 003 (28), 004 (12), census 001 (26) |
no has_mfa(), deactivation SQL only, professional statuses not modelled (BDR-026) |
| Anatomical library, curation | PARTIAL (back office) | nothing from the UI; operator CLI pnpm import:equine, pnpm assets:upload (local stack) |
sheet tables, RPCs, immutability, pgTAP 005 (127), 006, 007, 008, 011; Rust curation pipeline; app reads the bundled draft, never the DB | equine draft unpublished until professional review of REVIEW-REPORT (BDR-034/037); Step 13 provider and GC absent |
| Community sharing | PLANNED | nothing | fork_anatomical_sheet, set_sheet_visibility RPCs only |
Steps 17, 10, 11; verification gate (BDR-033) not wired: any active editor can make a sheet public at RPC level (DEV only) |
| i18n FR/EN | DONE (two gaps) | whole UI, sheet labels (878 + 111 descriptions), PDF labels in FR and EN; locale synced with the account | 350 keys each, i18n.dicts and i18n.keys tests | auth emails in default GoTrue English; APP_TAGLINE single-language; no lint rule against raw JSX strings |
| Mobile, accessibility | PARTIAL | responsive shell (drawer, 44 px hamburger), editor stacks below lg; device runs J1/J2 declared PASS |
shell.AppLayout 7, scripts/visual-canvas.mjs (manual) |
bottom tab bar not built; dialogs without focus trap or restore; canvas zones unreachable by keyboard; no axe test; no WCAG target |
| Admin, moderation | PLANNED (foundation) | nothing from the UI | append-only audit.audit_logs, log_event, 15 actions; not exposed through the API |
Step 25; admin MFA (IDENTITY §4) |
| Imports, lifecycle | PARTIAL | local-tool PDF/JSON import; account cascade to profile, roles, assets and purge queue | crates/core/src/pdf/read, STORAGE.md |
no export or deletion RPC; anatomical_sheets.creator_user_id on delete restrict blocks deleting a sheet creator; legal retention durations |
| Public web | PLANNED / DECISION | faunosteo.com serves the SPA (revision not recorded in the repo) | DEPLOY.md, ENVIRONMENTS.md | domain split (public site, /app, local tool), URL scheme (§27 vs Step 22), Q8 marked open although D-R8 (Astro) was validated |
Tests today: vitest app 446, core-wasm 60, supabase 40; cargo core 383, worker 33 native + 16 Docker sandbox; pgTAP 11 files,
446 planned assertions. No automated real-browser test of sign-up, login, account, the full editor flow or mobile navigation
(apps/app/e2e planned in TEST_STRATEGY §1, absent); no CI has ever run (BDR-047).
2. Usable today
The local tool (no account): new bilan, editor on the curated equine draft, PDF export, re-import, draft kept in the tab, FR/EN.
The account area on DEV: sign-up, login, recovery, profile, avatar. The two are not linked: being signed in changes nothing
in the tool (practitioner block from the localStorage cache, not from profiles).
3. Incomplete
Bilans live only in the tab and in the PDFs the user keeps. Clients and animals exist only as text in a bilan. The sheet in the database is never read by the app. Roles have no admin screen. Auth lacks OAuth, MFA, French emails and browser e2e.
4. Gaps with the vision
Multi-species (horse only, pipeline horse-specific), cabinets, verification and education statuses, agenda, booking, payments, notifications, community, admin, data lifecycle, public pages. Mobile-first: shell yes, tab bar and keyboard/a11y no. Plan text has drifted from the code: verification numbered Step 9 in the plan and Step 11 elsewhere; Steps 19, 21, 23 and BACKEND_ARCHITECTURE §6 still name a Node worker and Edge Functions retired by D-R9; Step 13 DoD says "seed v1 published" while BDR-037 keeps the draft unpublished; Step 13 and 17 cite deleted legacy tools; the role enum has 7 values in arch §4.1 and DOMAIN_MAP §1, 4 in code (BDR-026).
5. Roadmap proposal (to validate)
Principle: vertical steps, each usable end to end on DEV, mobile-first, FR/EN, species-generic data model; the plan's 27 steps kept, regrouped toward a first usable version (V1 = a signed-in practitioner keeps owners, animals and bilans in the cloud, with history and PDF, on phone and computer).
| Order | Step | Plan steps | Depends on | Needs decisions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| P0 | Plan refresh (docs only): renumber, retire Node worker/Edge mentions, Step 13 DoD without "published", close or reopen Q8, fold BDRs into OPEN_QUESTIONS | — | — | which OPEN_QUESTIONS are closed |
| V1-1 | Owners and animals of the practitioner (/app/clients, /app/animals/:id, create, edit, list, search; animal with species, sex, owner) |
12 (reduced) | 7, 8 | C4, C5, C6, consent text, whether cabinets enter the model now (10) |
| V1-2 | Sheet served from Supabase (SheetProvider on the DB, draft readable by the signed-in practitioner, read-only /app/anatomy) |
13 (reduced) | 3, 4, 8 | serve a draft to users before professional review, or wait for publication |
| V1-3 | Bilans saved in the cloud, linked to an animal, history per animal, draft/completed, copy from previous; local drafts migrated without loss | 14 (+ 11 skeleton if a quota applies) | V1-1, V1-2 | C11 quota, Q6(a) report-only points, whether the local tool stays |
| V1-4 | Stored PDF artifacts and export from a saved bilan (locale recorded, C14) | 15 (reduced) | V1-3 | Q1 |
| V1-5 | Mobile and accessibility pass on those screens (tab bar, dialog focus, keyboard path in the canvas, axe in tests) | design README, TEST_STRATEGY | V1-1 to V1-4 | WCAG target |
| Next | Cabinets 10, verification 9 + admin MFA, entitlements 11 → billing 23, notifications 19 → agenda 20 → travel 21, public web 22, sheet editor 17 → community 18, imports 24, admin 25, lifecycle 26, hardening 27 | per step |
Technical risks that really block: C4 decides the shape of the client tables, which are hard to change once data exists; the
report contract is frozen while Q6 is open (a later localAnnotations definition is a version bump); the sessionStorage →
server switch can lose drafts if not migrated; Q2 (hosting) blocks any production backend.
6. First recommended step: V1-1 « Propriétaires et animaux »
Why first: every later vertical (cloud bilans, history, agenda, reminders, sharing) needs an animal and its owner; it needs no provider (Q7), no payment, no publication of the sheet. It needs owner decisions C4, C5 and C6 first.
Acceptance criteria (draft, to validate with the decisions):
- A signed-in practitioner creates, edits, lists and searches owners (name, contact fields decided by the owner) and animals
(name, species from
species, sex, breed, birth date or age, owner link), on phone (375 px) and computer, FR and EN. - Another practitioner never sees them (RLS by owner, allowed and denied pgTAP cases, cross-account test on the real stack).
- Every write goes through an audited RPC or an owner-scoped policy as the decision on C4 requires; tables ship with RLS in the migration that creates them, regenerated types, PGlite and real-stack pgTAP.
- Validation rules (formats, lengths, required fields) live in
crates/coreand are reached through the wasm facade (BDR-043); the forms keep Zod for i18n messages only. - Screens follow
docs/design/(Clients, Animaux entries; bottom tab bar on mobile); keyboard and screen reader can complete the forms; an axe check runs in the suite. - Deleting or archiving an owner or animal follows the owner's rule (anonymise vs keep, BDR-033(7)), tested.
pnpm check:allgreen, fresh verifier and security gates, no change to the bilan format.