17 KiB
CODE-CLEAN AUDIT — whole repository (claude-config), 2026-10-12 — r3
r2 = r1 after the 3-lens challenge (correctness FATAL(6), robustness FATAL(5), simplicity CONCERNS(5)). r3 = r2 after the confirmation pass (correctness CONCERNS(2): B18 half void, C3 without a stderr oracle; 5 MINOR). Every BLOCKER/MAJOR is closed by a named change below or tagged [deferred 2026-10-12] for the human gate.
Proposed cleanup scope (KIND = proposals). Iron law: zero behavior change —
identical observable output before and after every item; the items that DO
carry a delta are tagged delta: explicitly (B3, C2).
Scanned: 98 shell files (~16.5K lines, incl. the 4 git hooks × 2 copies),
13 Python files (~2.3K lines), 2 TypeScript files (8.6K lines, the
model-router mod), Makefile. Markdown/JSON are out of scope.
Norms source: CLAUDE.global.md limits (25 logic lines/function, 80 chars/line,
5 params, 5 locals; comments and error-handling boilerplate NOT counted) +
project CLAUDE.md Health Stack (shellcheck *.sh hooks/*.sh lib/*.sh — a
non-recursive glob: lib/tests/ and lib/seo-data/ are outside it, exit 0
today). No .editorconfig / .shellcheckrc / pyproject / tsconfig tracked.
Tools: shellcheck (37 notes in 4 files, 0 errors); AST scan for Python;
regex scan for TypeScript; logic-line counter for shell, re-run in r2 WITH
the error-handling exclusion (err/warn/info/ok lines, >&2 diagnostics,
return N, except/raise/sys.exit, degraded returns); word-boundary
reference census for every function and script; diff for duplicate blocks.
Baseline: make test all 46 suites green, exit 0 (2026-10-12 00:5x).
Format: file:line — description — severity — proposed fix
═══ DEAD CODE ═══
A1. lib/seo-data/safe_fetch.py:30 — import gzip unused (gzip appears only in
comments at :137 and :153) — warn — delete the import line. The gzip
token in the stdlib-only ALLOWLIST at lib/seo-data/seo-data.test.sh:143
stays: it is a list of permitted stdlib names, not a usage assertion.
Checked and NOT listed:
- lib/detect-plugins.sh:28
detect_gstack, :41detect_plugin_dev: zero literal callers but CALLED by constructed name at hooks/session-start.sh:80 ("detect_$plugin"). Live. Do not delete. - No commented-out code; no TODO/FIXME/XXX/HACK in executable code (the two
shortcut:markers, lib/floor-guard.sh:106 and register.ts:3423, are by-design, dated 2026-09-28 / 2026-10-09). - TypeScript: 0 symbols with ≤1 reference; only export is
register. - Python: 0 dead locals, 0 unused functions.
- Every lib/.sh, lib/.py, hooks/*.sh has ≥1 non-test caller.
═══ STYLE VIOLATIONS ═══
B1. lib/seo-data/seo-data.test.sh (27 sites, SC2015 [ … ] && ok … || no …;
ok/no never fail) — warn, outside the Health Stack glob — insert on
line 3, BEFORE set -u (a directive after the first command scopes to the
next command only; r1 had it wrong):
# shellcheck disable=SC2015 # A && ok || no is deliberate (ok/no never fail)
— the convention of lib/tests/effort-routing.test.sh:8/:9. Prove:
shellcheck lib/seo-data/seo-data.test.sh exits 0. Zero behavior change.
B2. lib/tests/url-guard.test.sh:21,22,33,34,60,61 and
lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh:108-110 (SC2016: single-quoted $(…) /
backticks are the commands under test) — warn, outside the Health Stack
glob — file-level # shellcheck disable=SC2016 # single-quoted forms are the commands under test placed BEFORE the first command (url-guard line
3, push-guard line 5), as lib/tests/guard-bash.test.sh:5. Prove: shellcheck
exits 0 on both.
B3. lib/tests/run-review-guards.sh:14 — cd "$REPO" unguarded (SC2164);
under set -uo pipefail a failed cd runs every guard in the wrong
directory — warn — cd "$REPO" || exit 1. delta: cd-failure path only
(silent wrong-dir run → loud exit 1).
B4. hooks/design-toolchain-reminder.sh:51 — one 972-char regex literal — warn
— split into pattern='…' + pattern+='|…' lines ≤80 chars, IN THE
CURRENT ALTERNATIVE ORDER (no regrouping: the sha256 must match). This
hook runs live on every UserPromptSubmit of every session (settings.json
wires ~/.claude/hooks → repo hooks/); a syntax error = exit 2 = every
prompt blocked. Procedure: build on a scratch copy, bash -n, then
printf '%s' "$pattern" | sha256sum old vs new must match, then the
suite lib/tests/design-toolchain-reminder.test.sh run on the copy — the
suite hardcodes $H=<root>/hooks/design-toolchain-reminder.sh (:4), so
build a mirror tree $T/hooks/<copy> + $T/lib/tests/<suite copy> and
run the suite from there, never edit the suite — then land it in ONE
write. Zero behavior change.
B5. lib/toggle-external.sh:257 — enable_tool() 49 logic lines after the
error-handling exclusion (max 25) — warn — split by case arm:
enable_gstack, enable_external_single (the 11-name arm, darwin-skill
src branch included), enable_pack (21st|higgsfield); enable_tool
keeps only the dispatch case. Every ok/warn/err string and return
code unchanged. Lines 1-32 of the file untouched (usage() prints 3-26).
Coverage: enable gstack by lib/tests/gstack-removed.test.sh:43,55; the
darwin-skill branch has NO suite → golden capture mandatory (see
EXECUTOR CONSTRAINTS).
B7. lib/profile.sh:321 — enable_skill() 41 logic lines — warn — extract the
three large arms: enable_gstack_skill, enable_linked_skill
(external|personal; NOT "managed", a term of art for the MANAGED_*
allowlists), enable_plugin_skill (plugin@); the plugin / mcp / cli
arms stay inline. Twin of toggle-external's arms (see C5), kept separate:
merging changes messages. Golden capture mandatory: the profile suites
discard output (>/dev/null 2>&1).
B9. lib/profile.sh:575 — cmd_show() 32 logic lines AND 14 distinct locals
(max 5; outcome: logic lines ≤25 per function, locals reduced, NOT to
≤5 — whichever helper keeps the header still holds prof/file/desc/
skills/pl/m/c/total) — warn — extract _show_plain "$prof" (the --plain branch) and
_show_grouped "$prof"; each helper takes $prof and iterates
read_profile itself. NO local -n (zero namerefs in the repo, bash
≥4.3 only). _show_plain MUST end with an explicit return 0: profile.sh
runs set -euo pipefail and the loop's last [ … ] && printf returns 1
whenever the last entry is not cli (dev/qa/seo today) — without it the
helper's rc 1 kills the script after printing (reproduced), and
lib/design-tool-gate.sh:202 turns that into exit 2. No suite runs the
real cmd_show (design-tool-gate.test.sh fakes profile.sh) → characterization
oracle: stdout + rc of bash lib/profile.sh show <p> and show <p> --plain for EVERY lib/profiles/.profile, captured before and after,
byte-identical. Grouped mode calls claude plugin list / claude mcp list live via skill_status (:270-297): run both captures with the same
fixed CLAUDE_BIN stub so session state cannot drift between them.
minimal.profile (0 entries) covers the Total: 0 branch.
B11. lib/seo-data/google_seo.py:217 — _cli() 40 logic lines — warn —
extract _build_parser() (the four sub-parsers; name already used by
content_quality.py and schema_gen.py) and _dispatch(args); the
try/except envelope (bad_usage / degraded) stays in _cli. The
bad_usage path has no test → golden capture of stdout + rc for one
bad invocation and each of the 4 verbs in mock mode.
B13. Borderline (26–29 logic lines after the exclusion) — info — leave; a
split for 1–4 lines is churn: lib/toggle-external.sh:207 disable_tool
(28), lib/profile.sh:416 disable_skill (27), lib/seo-data/sitemap.py:133
sitemap (29, 6-8 lines are except→degraded returns), doctor.sh:340
inspect_automode (28), lib/design-tool-gate.sh:160 tool_active (27),
lib/profile.sh:252 skill_status (27), lib/profile.sh:671 cmd_gstack (27),
skills/client-handover/scripts/handover-to-pdf.sh:154 tag_bare_url_links
(27), lib/seo-data/tokenstore.py:85 _cli (26), register.ts:3314
registerSpawn (26), :3344 registerTurns (26). (r1's B6/B8/B12 land here.)
Dropped as a false positive: r1 B10 lib/doc-commit.sh:77 commit_docs —
18 logic lines once its four fail-closed blocks (rc 3/3/4/5) are
excluded; a split would scatter the BDR-022 guard that IS the file and
break the shape match with its twin commit_memory (memory-commit.sh:51).
B14. Over the limit but not logic — info — leave: hooks/push-guard.sh:99
simple_cmds (one awk program); lib/doctor-vendored.sh:80 and
lib/vendor-skills.sh:91 (embedded Python heredocs); lib/profile.sh:755
usage (help text); lib/tests/profile-census.test.sh:41 census_check
(embedded Python); register.ts:896 newState (one 43-field literal), :560
mergeConfig (one return literal), :1607 handleCommand (flat switch);
register.test.ts:59/:130/:3610 (fixtures).
B15. Params > 5: lib/seo-data/schema_gen.py:20 reservation (9), :85
discussion (8), :111 profile (8); google_seo.py:101 queries (6) — info —
keyword-only, mirror the CLI flags one-to-one, one caller each. Leave.
B16. Locals > 5 (norm listed, r1 had no section) — info — leave; census from
the correctness lens, verified only for cmd_show (14, reduced not
closed by B9):
lib/vendor-skills.sh vendor_pinned_skills (~11), lib/gstack-playwright.sh
gstack_browsers_report (~9), _vendor_install_skill / profile.sh
count_profile / cmd_list (~8 each), google_seo.py _cli (8, reduced by
B11). Not proposed: each is a sequential CLI/report body; splitting for
the count alone is churn.
B17. Lines > 80 chars: 1273 in 78 shell files, 46 in Python (6 of them
docstrings), 5 in TypeScript — info — ALL DEFERRED to "enforce on new
code" (r1 proposed the Python/TS subset; dropped: no formatter tracked so
it would not hold, 5 of google_seo's lines sit inside B11's _cli, and
the register.ts lines are in a live-loaded mod with a make test gate
that SKIPs when claude plugin test is absent). Lines MOVED by B5, B7,
B9, B11, C3 keep their current length (toggle-external.sh:280, 285-287,
325, 334; deploy-commit.sh:53, :55; profile.sh:349, 385, 393, 402 are
>80 today): rewrapping a message string can change output. B17 applies
only to lines newly written in this run (function headers, calls).
B18. lib/profile.sh:188 (gstack_skills) and lib/toggle-external.sh:167
(gstack_skills) — for d in loops with no local d: d leaks as a
global (norm: no global state); no reader of $d outside those loops,
and every caller reads the function through < <(gstack_skills …)
(profile.sh:507, toggle-external.sh:181, :222), so the leak never
reaches a caller — warn — add local d in each. r2 also listed
toggle-external.sh:70 and :98: FALSE, both already declare local d
(:69, :97); dropped. Same class, same fix, added in r3:
toggle-external.sh:263 for entry in (inside the gstack arm B5 moves
into enable_gstack — declare local entry there) and :344 for t in
(cmd_status → local t). Zero behavior change.
B19. lib/toggle-external.sh:119-121 — comment says "this script takes no extra
source" but :50 sources lib/gstack-removed.sh and both fixture suites
copy it alongside (higgsfield.test.sh:180,
toggle-external-repo-resolution.test.sh:20) — info — reword the comment.
B20. lib/detect-plugins.sh:4 — header "Sourced by:" omits update-all.sh:19 —
info — add it.
═══ STRUCTURAL ISSUES ═══
C1. [deferred 2026-10-12] lib/gitflow-test.sh — only suite outside lib/tests/
and only -test.sh name (38 siblings are lib/tests/*.test.sh). r1
proposed a move; BOTH challengers (correctness, robustness) BLOCKED it:
the file resolves 22 paths from $HERE (15× $HERE/gitflow.sh, 7×
$HERE/../), and :434/:442 guard T19a-e with [ -d "$HERE/../.githooks" ]
— after a move those fall to lib/.githooks (absent) and print
ok "T19 skipped", silently voiding the ONLY drift lock on post-commit /
post-merge / reference-transaction. Plus: 14 CHECK: lines in 7 durable
contracts run the old path, .gitleaks.toml:56,59 cite it, lib/tests/ is
outside the Health Stack glob, and the == lib/gitflow-test.sh line /
suite order of make test change. Cosmetic payoff. Deferred: not in this
run unless the human explicitly asks; the safe form would be
HERE="$(cd "$(dirname "$0")/.." && pwd)" plus every citer, with a
grep -c 'ok T19' before/after proof.
C2. skills/prune-memory/tests/run-deterministic.sh — hermetic deterministic
suite (mktemp sandbox, 5 oracles, ALL GREEN today) absent from Makefile
SUITES — info, delta: make test gains one suite block and one new way
to go red — add the LITERAL tracked path
skills/prune-memory/tests/run-deterministic.sh to Makefile:31 (NOT a
skills/*/… glob: skills/ holds symlinks to vendored and out-of-repo
trees, a glob would execute unreviewed third-party tests and make the
suite set machine-dependent). Caveat for the human: the suite executes
bash blocks extracted from prune-memory SKILL.md headings, so wiring it
locks that doc's headings under make test.
C3. lib/deploy-commit.sh:51-57 and :62-68 — verbatim identical 7-line
REFUSED block (diff empty) in the pending and commit arms — warn —
hoist into _refuse_outside_allowlist "$@" (local violations; mapfile -t violations … + the { … } >&2; exit 4 block). Define it
with the other _ helpers ABOVE line 46 (the script runs set -uo pipefail without -e: a helper defined after esac would give rc 127
and the arm would carry on to git add out-of-scope paths); call it as
a plain statement so exit 4 ends the script exactly as today, and
keep the post-shift "$@" (:60). stderr text byte-identical — but
lib/tests/deploy-commit.test.sh runs every rc-4 case with >/dev/null 2>&1 (:19, :22, :26, :46) and checks rc + commit count only, and the
calling skill parses the REFUSED text (deploy-commit.sh:13-15) → golden
capture of stdout + stderr + rc, before and after, in a mkrepo-style
sandbox for pending src.txt, commit x src.txt and one mixed
in-scope + out-of-scope call.
C4. [done 2026-10-12 via /refactor, refactorer on chore/code-clean — was deferred] lib/toggle-external.sh — the same 10/11-name tool
list repeated at :58-63, :184-186, :225-228, :285-288 (+ header :20-32):
adding a tool takes 5 edits — info — resolve the kind once from a single
array (membership idiom already at :101). Not in this run: it reshapes
the case arms B5 splits and the status_tool arm order; a follow-up
/refactor after B5 lands.
C5. [done 2026-10-12 via /refactor, refactorer on chore/code-clean — was deferred] Twin implementations across lib/profile.sh and
lib/toggle-external.sh: gstack_skills (:184 / :164, same loop),
enable_all_gstack (:479) vs the enable gstack arm (:261), the external
from-source path (:363 says "mirrors toggle-external.sh") — info —
merging changes messages, not zero-behavior; logged for a design pass.
B5/B7 name their helpers so the twin relation stays visible.
BUG TO LOG (executor appends to .claude/audits/BUGS-FOUND.md, never fixes):
- lib/toggle-external.sh:350 usage() prints header lines 3-26 only; the
managed-tool list continues to :32, so
--helpomits 8 of 14 tools.
Checked, not an issue: githooks/ and .githooks/ byte-identical (by design); lib/seo-data/seo-data.test.sh co-located with its engine; .claude/tasks/ contracts/*.{sh,py} durable oracles, out of scope; profile.sh's unprefixed CLI-style function names, per-file convention.
EXECUTOR CONSTRAINTS (apply to every approved item):
- Golden capture BEFORE any edit, diff AFTER: stdout, stderr, rc (and the fixture tree where a mv/rm arm is moved) for every moved arm and CLI verb — the suites that "cover" B5/B7/B9/B11/C3 discard output or fake the script.
- Hook-safe landing for B4 (scratch copy → bash -n → sha256 → suite → one write). No edit to register.ts in this run.
- No
local -n, no new bash ≥4 construct, no new dependency. - Return codes: toggle-external.sh:40 and profile.sh:49 run
set -euo pipefail. Call every extracted helper (B5, B7, B9) as a PLAIN statement — neverhelper || …,helper && …,if helper,! helper: those switch errexit OFF inside the helper, so a failedmv(toggle-external.sh:273, profile.sh:330) that aborts with rc 1 today would instead continue and printok …with rc 0, a path no golden capture exercises. A plain call keepsreturn 1(toggle-external.sh:305, :326) → errexit in the caller → exit 1 through main (:359), as today. C3 usesexit, notreturn, and is covered by its own placement rule. make testfull run after; shellcheck on every touched file.
TOTALS: 0 blocking, 11 warn (A1, B1, B2, B3, B4, B5, B7, B9, B11, B18, C3), 8 info (B13–B17, B19, B20, C2 — of which B13–B17 propose no change), 3 deferred for the human (C1, C4, C5), 1 bug to log.