Files
faunosteo/.claude/audits/2026-10-29-v1-2-2-evidence.md
T

8.9 KiB

V1-2.2 evidence (2026-10-29)

Owner brief « Autorisation de démarrer V1-2.2 », V1-2.1 VERIFIED at ac71c5b. Worktree feature/v1-2-anatomical-sheets. Code commits 64a4384, cf37aa2, 8ae7565, docs 741c25c. Contract docs/development/V1-2_ANATOMICAL_SHEETS.md §16.3; verifier contract .claude/tasks/contracts/2026-10-29-v1-2-2-core.md; record docs/development/RUST.md §12.

1. Owner answers taken before the code (contract §17.4)

Question Answer
No Inkscape, Illustrator, Figma or Affinity on the machine: how to get real editor exports the owner supplies them (crates/core/tests/fixtures/svg/exports/owner/); cairo and ImageMagick exports committed meanwhile
Strict-parse failure code (§6.5 vs §6.7) verification.integrity.document
Draft preview with caps excess or missing drawings reported for drafts, refused for published and deprecated versions

2. Gates on the working tree before the commits

Gate Result
pnpm rust:check exit 0; 201 cargo result lines, 1 849 passed, 0 failed, 3 ignored (every feature run of the script); clippy -D warnings clean; cargo deny: bans, licenses, sources ok
pnpm wasm:build 1 771 003 B raw, 582 722 B gzip -9 (script); core-wasm proofs green
pnpm check exit 0; core-wasm 16 files 65 tests, supabase 11 files 128 tests, app 65 files 566 tests; lint clean; app build done
size budget (packages/core-wasm/tests/size.test.ts) 592 136 B by Node's gzip ≤ 600 000 B (531 715 B before V1-2.2)

The first build was 635 654 B gzip (over budget): serde's tagged readers for EditCommand / NewElement and an owned-Value read of the document each compiled a second copy of the schema's reader. Reading both through &Value gave 606 750 B, then 582 722 B.

3. New suites (cargo, debug)

Suite Tests Notes
sheet_size 6 17 PostgreSQL vectors (PGlite 17.5, oracles/v1-2-2/size.json); seed 184 105 B = the real image's value
sheet_review 9 equine 188 / 31 / 620 over 839 elements, 30 groups
sheet_verdict 13 at every cap: 493 ms debug, 107 ms release, document 1 165 850 B
sheet_preview 8 index tables and canvases equal to the bundled LoadedSheet
sheet_edit 11 400 random commands on two documents
svg_clean 8 42 hostile files; 3 000 generated: 123 clean, 2 697 cleanable (fixpoint), 180 cycles refused
packages/core-wasm/tests/preview.test.ts 5 shipped module; clean_svg slowest 0.4 ms over 45 inputs

4. Mutation run

Script: .claude/audits/2026-10-29-v1-2-2-mutations.py (run from the repository root: each mutant applied, its suite run, the file restored).

Mutant Suite Result
caps > → >= sheet_verdict killed
digest without its group key sheet_review killed by a_removal_digest_is_bound_to_its_group_key, written for it before the run
event handlers not active svg_clean killed
drawing hash unchecked sheet_verdict killed
content update keeps reviewed sheet_edit killed
fingerprint unchecked at load sheet_preview killed
inherited counted as read sheet_review survived the first run; killed once an_inherited_element_alone_keeps_its_group_uncoverable was added
redrawn views ignored sheet_edit killed
numeric scale ignored sheet_size killed
removal groups never made sheet_review killed

5. DEV and protected branches

  • No Supabase CLI call, no SQL, no migration, no seed, no worker start in this step. The DEV containers (supabase_*_faunosteo) were read with docker ps / docker inspect only: started 2026-10-28 14:45 UTC, before this session (supabase_auth_faunosteo restarts=3 already then). Snapshot before the gate: scratchpad/docker-inspect-before.txt; after: section 6.
  • No merge, no checkout of develop, main or release/*; commits only on feature/v1-2-anatomical-sheets, pushed by the post-commit hook.

6. Gates on the committed branch and reviews

Commit pnpm check:all Reviews
741c25c exit 0, every stage, e2e:ui PASSED verifier ECARTS(6); security PASS (2 MEDIUM, 2 LOW) — fixed in 8294d54
8294d54 exit 0 verifier ECARTS(3) (A6 owner exports, A12 outside its commands, helper unrecorded); security PASS (4 MEDIUM, 8 LOW) — fixed in ca31b78 except the owner decisions of RUST.md §12.6
ca31b78 exit 0; cargo 1 879 passed 0 failed; vitest core-wasm 65, supabase 128, app 566; e2e:ui PASSED; module 596 671 B (Node gzip) ≤ 600 000 —

The first two reviewers (Fable 5.1) stopped at once on exhausted usage credits and produced nothing; they ran again on Opus. e2e:shell not run (needs the sandbox stack; no screen changed).

Containers after the gates (docker inspect, read-only): identical to the snapshot of section 5 (DEV supabase_*_faunosteo and the V1-2.1 sandbox: same start times and restart counts).

Known: commit 64a4384 alone does not build (facade::clean_svg names the module of cf37aa2); the branch head does.

7. Owner arbitrations at the checkpoint (brief « V1-2.2 : arbitrages du propriétaire et finalisation », on 17d9199)

Owner answers (2026-10-29, contract §17.4 last six rows): references refused when dangling and canvas ids scoped per view, implemented in V1-2.2 (not deferred); one stored form for every upload, verdict and preview refusing another; strict numeric colours kept; remove refused atomically while named; Inkscape fetched for real exports; the wasm debug name section dropped. Commits: e823655 (SVG), bb5efa0 (removal), 661212a (build flag), 93e4e81 (docs), 5281337 (contract criteria B1-B8, mutation script), a678faa (strict url( after the security review), then the review LOWs and this evidence.

Gate Result
pnpm check:all on 5281337 exit 0; cargo 1 949 passed, 0 failed, 3 ignored; core-wasm 65, supabase 128, app 566; e2e:ui 26 passed; app image, worker test stage, worker runtime image
pnpm check:all on a678faa exit 0; cargo 1 959 passed, 0 failed, 3 ignored; same suites green; module 1 512 071 B raw, 558 793 B gzip -9, 568 625 B by Node's gzip (budget 600 000, margin 31 375 B)
first run on the working tree stopped at the committed-types guard only (DrawingResult.ts, SvgCleaning.ts regenerated, not yet committed); every stage before it green
mutations (2026-10-29-v1-2-2-mutations-arbitrations.py) A1-A12 on 5281337: 12 killed (A11 first written so it did not compile, rewritten, killed); A13-A17 after a678faa: 4 killed, A17 (% taken into the id run) survives as an equivalent mutant, is_reference_name refusing % either way (A14 kills the grammar check itself)
protected readers, N-1 copies, frozen oracles, goldens, supabase/ no file changed (git diff --name-only 17d9199)
DEV and sandbox containers docker inspect identical before and after every gate (start times, restart counts)

Reviews (fresh; the pinned Fable 5.1 had no credits left and the Opus alias answered model_not_found, so both ran on Sonnet):

Round Verifier Security
17d9199..5281337 ECARTS(2): B4 LOW (érgb(, rgurl(#b( passed the colour exception), A6 open; doc drift BLOCK(1) HIGH: url(#%61) (and Chromium's url('#<TAB>a')) passed the dangling check, the scoping and the expansion budget, resolving in Chromium 1248 and Firefox 1555 (budget hole pre-existing since R3); MEDIUM scope unique per document only; 3 LOW
5281337..a678faa ECARTS(2): A6 open; B10 LOW (stale size figures, one wording in ANNOTATION-RENDERING); owner procedure not precise enough PASS; MEDIUM carried as a written requirement; LOWs: composer check shares the reader's parser, no test delivers a real tab, TS helper oracle, mutation script
pnpm check:all on f1ef6a4 (final code) exit 0; cargo 1 959 passed, 0 failed; core-wasm 65, supabase 128, app 566; e2e:ui 26; Docker stages; module 1 512 413 B raw, 558 859 B gzip -9, 568 696 B by Node's gzip (margin 31 304 B) —
after the LOWs fixed in f1ef6a4: sizes, wording and counts in RUST.md; a coarse url( count in the composer check that shares no parser; &#9;, &#10;, &#13; spellings in svg_clean; the owner procedure rewritten (same source file, live-text variants, --nocapture, date in the name, Affinity) —

Inkscape provenance: not installed; inkscape.org 504 then timeout; apt-get download of inkscape_1.4.3-0ubuntu2_amd64.deb (sha256 24a2e9225c2cdcaad8f3e36a8b7a0f5a68db58ed67fc6f67455395fdd918326e, equal to apt-cache show) and 22 library packages into the session scratch folder, dpkg-deb -x, run with LD_LIBRARY_PATH (no install, no sudo).

Open at the checkpoint: A6 (Illustrator, Figma, Affinity exports from the owner); the MEDIUM (a page inlining two documents needs a per-document prefix); the probe folder of the first security review, whose deletion the permission rules refused (scratchpad/probe-audit of session 0cee2841), to be removed by the owner.