4.7 KiB
CONTRACT: R5.6 switch rehearsal (isolated), owner brief 2026-10-24 « Validation de la préparation R5.6 et corrections préalables à la bascule »
- branch
feature/rust-r5-pipeline-coreat943a25a(official state, inactive); patch.claude/tasks/plans/r5-6-switch.patch - rehearsal: detached worktree
/tmp/claude-1000/-home-bchanot-Documents-faunosteo/3571c861-cd6e-4751-a25e-c26da95beb85/scratchpad/r56wt=943a25a+ the patch, seed switched there only
Clauses
S1. M1 option 1. On export, an old report whose stamp is the registered historical value of the same sheet, against the
sheet's verified canonical value, archives a snapshot carrying the report's own stamp; only for the registered pair of the
same sheet id, with the loaded sheet's v1 value recomputed from its document at load; never from an archive's alias list; a
new report keeps the canonical value. Tests cover the owner's 9 scenarios (old PDF import, no rebase, re-export coherent,
current reader, frozen N-1 reader, labels/views/annotations/branding preserved, rollback reader, forged/unknown refused, real
change rebases), not only hash equality.
S2. Scope. Rust changes only in report/rebase.rs, archive/read.rs (unchanged allowed), session.rs,
pdf/write/input.rs, pdf/compare/lines.rs, sheet/loaded.rs, facade.rs, bin/report_compare.rs, plus the
sheet/fingerprint.rs module, the generator (curation/draft/pipeline.rs), Cargo/tests/scripts; archive and envelope checks not
loosened; public errors kept where possible; N-1 readers untouched.
S3. v0/v1 loading. A reference without a block is historical (v0): loads as before, unverified, no alias privilege, never
v1. A present block is strict (known keys, v1 convention, 64 lowercase hex, not an alias value, aliases only from the
registry for this sheet and value, value recomputed from the document); any contradiction refused.
S4. Artifacts and oracles. In the switched seed only sheet-ref.json and report-migration-map.json differ; their value
and block are consistent with v1; document.json, horse.svg, equine_draft.sql byte-identical; no R2-R5 oracle or golden
changed; O7, O10, the R2 Zod oracle, the R5.1 ledger and the app goldens run in their original (pre-switch) context, with a
separate test of the post-switch behaviour; every declared difference targeted, tested, unable to hide an anatomical change.
S5. report:compare. The alias line keeps the draft/published status and prints both raw values; other differences still reported.
S6. Generators. pnpm import:equine → the Rust pipeline; import:equine:legacy → the TypeScript one; historical tests use
the generator they refer to.
S7. Isolation. The official branch state stays inactive (seed 27c7…, no new convention active), no DB/Supabase mutation,
no oracle regenerated, nothing deleted.
S8. Gates on the switched state. pnpm rust:check, pnpm check:all, RFC 8785, Node differential, alias security, the five
consumers + load checks, authentic archive parity, N-1 on re-exported archives, snapshot-bearing reports, real-change rebase,
the two generated artifacts; security audit; fresh verifier.
Clarifications
-
2026-10-25 (owner « autorisation de correction M1, nouvelle répétition obligatoire »): scope extended by
domain/archive/snapshot_rules.rs; the M1 decision moves intobuild_sheet_snapshotandassert_exportable(pdf/write/input.rs) returns to strict equality (unchanged from943a25a). Rules added: an alias is granted only byLoadedSheet::recognises_historical_stamp(loader-verifiedv1value, private state, recomputed from the current document at the decision, registry pair, same sheet id);"fingerprint": nulland malformed blocks refused; warnings never block av1fingerprint (is_publishable), errors do;canonical_jsonbounded at 128 levels with a controlled error; the direct export API is tested, not only the application paths. Final state: worktree/tmp/claude-1000/-home-bchanot-Documents-faunosteo/3571c861-cd6e-4751-a25e-c26da95beb85/scratchpad/r56final(detached at8e77e37+ the patch, seed switched by the patch). -
2026-10-25 (owner « Autorisation officielle de la bascule R5.6 »): S7 (isolation) is superseded for the activation: the owner authorised the official switch on
feature/rust-r5-pipeline-core(commit9e87016) withequivalencecrate-private, stale comments fixed, the trust boundary documented, and the regeneration of exactlydraft/sheet-ref.jsonanddraft/report-migration-map.json(procedure: fresh temporary--out, comparison, the two files only,--check). The other S7 parts still hold: no database or Supabase mutation, no oracle regenerated, nothing deleted, no merge.