Files
faunosteo/.claude/audits/2026-10-25-rust-r5-6-rehearsal-verify.md

1.5 KiB

R5.6 rehearsal — fresh verifier (Opus), persisted by the orchestrator (verifier is read-only)

Contract .claude/tasks/contracts/2026-10-25-rust-r5-6-rehearsal.md, patch at 82e2e43, worktree switched.

VERIFY — VERDICT: ECARTS(3)

  • S1 NOT-MET: export path (pdf/write/input.rs assert_exportable :205, keep_the_report_stamp :238) grants the pair from the snapshot's claimed value, never reads fingerprint_verified. Probe: v0 sheet-ref (no block) + demo report 27c7 + core build_sheet_snapshot → export succeeds 27c7/27c7 (pre-patch: sheet_mismatch). App store flow cannot reach it (rebase checks the flag). Rest of S1 met (one direction, same sheet, registry only, new report canonical, 9 scenarios tested).
  • S2 MET (8 Rust files in scope, archive/read.rs and session.rs unchanged, archive check strict, invalid_sheet / sheet_mismatch kept, no n-1 change)
  • S3 NOT-MET: load conforms; v0 snapshot gets alias privilege at export (same root cause)
  • S4 MET (2 files differ, value + block v1, document/horse.svg/SQL identical, no oracle/golden changed, original contexts + post-switch twins, O10 77 rows pinned)
  • S5 MET, S6 MET, S7 MET (main tree inert, patch applies on HEAD)
  • S8 NOT-MET: alias-security gate fails for the export consumer; everything else green (rust:check RC 0, suites listed, vitest 41/41, rollback report-compare reads the re-export with snapshot kept)
  • FLOOR clean. Notes: stale pnpm import:equine comments (scripts/import-equine.sh:8, CLAUDE.md); verifier overwrote its own scratch probe folder (session scratch only).