chore(memory): BDR-074, EVAL-036, V1-1.1 journal, TODO, gate contract

This commit is contained in:
bchanot committed 2026-10-25 20:08:33 +01:00
1 parent 0f8c9833cc
commit 6bf69787cb
5 files changed
+90 -4

No files matched your search

+8
View File
@@ -542,3 +542,11 @@ Decision (owner brief « V1-1 : ratification des décisions métier et préparat
Still open: D10-D14, D17 (UI); technical design (SQL/RLS/RPC, N1-N9, D15 thresholds, U1-U3) awaits owner validation at V1-1 preparation checkpoint; no migration before. Contract restructured: verification now §6.2 (BDR-072 cites old §5.2).
Alt: keep proposals open; global client record (2026-10-08 plan Step 12); `owner_user_id` column instead of workspaces.
Status: active. Branch `feature/v1-1-clients-animals` off develop 5502617. Contract `docs/development/V1-1_OWNERS_ANIMALS.md` §13.1.
## BDR-074 | 2026-10-25 | V1-1 architecture + N1-N9 validated by owner; V1-1.1 M1 workspaces built in isolation
Decision (owner brief « Validation du contrat V1-1 et autorisation de V1-1.1 Workspaces »): V1-1 model accepted as target (workspaces + members, one personal ws per practitioner, cabinets later as shared ws, no organizations table, isolation per ws, clients person|structure, animals per ws, N-N relations, composite FKs, D-R7 TS forms + SQL CHECK boundary, RLS at creation, RPC writes). 6-step split accepted; only V1-1.1 authorised. N1 9 species + other, rows not enum, ids unchanged (Rust species_id free string, SQL CHECK fits). N2 no first/last names. N3 client notes deferred. N4 CHANGED: logical voiding (`voided_at`, `void_animal_client_relation`) ≠ end; voided never shown current/former, no invented `ended_on`, minimised audit; delete RPC dropped. N5 dates optional, never invented, ordered; CHECKs written in contract §5.3. N6 caps approved, write budget PER WORKSPACE (1000/h, 5000/day), concurrency-safe (no bare count+insert), mechanism fixed with M2. N7 service_role minimisation w/o claiming admin paths closed; existing tables/global privileges untouched. N8 sex none preselected. N9 no staff general view; audit = technical ids, op, time, result, bounded correlation; metadata `{workspace_id}` only (relation_role dropped). D10-D14, D17, U1-U3 stay contract-level; tab-bar contradiction → V1-1.3.
M1 as built (`20261025100000_workspaces.sql`): creation = server init in sign-up tx (trigger on profiles → `private.ensure_personal_workspace` one-statement CTE, ON CONFLICT on named unique `workspaces_personal_user_unique`); deferred constraint triggers `workspaces_personal_holder`/`workspace_members_personal_holder` (personal ws = exactly its account as holder, any writer); backfill once; `caller_workspace_ids` (active + email confirmed, auth.uid only) EXECUTE authenticated; `writable_workspace_ids` EXECUTE none; revoke all incl. service_role on new tables/functions; log_event correlation cap + NOT VALID CHECK.
Deviations: `packages/supabase/src/workspaces.ts` → V1-1.2 (no consumer); `db:reset && db:test` on DEV replaced by isolated sandbox (owner kept DEV untouched).
Alt: workspace created at first authorised login (client-triggered, forgeable timing, partial-state risk); invariant only by grants (owner-role bugs undetected); per-actor budget (cabinet-blind).
Status: active. M1 not applied to DEV (owner action, SUPABASE.md §3.3). Contract §5.3, §8.1, §9, §10, §13.2.
+7
View File
@@ -253,3 +253,10 @@ Action: V1-1 contract §1 + §8.3 follow D-R7. Check every proposal against Anne
Method: plan-challenger ×3 (correctness, robustness, simplicity) on `V1-1_OWNERS_ANIMALS.md` before owner checkpoint; evidence read from migrations, harness, worker config, react-router dist.
Anomaly: draft claimed (1) N7 service_role revoke → "D16 holds at key level" (false: service key = GoTrue admin key → magic link / set password → user session); (2) identical 42501 while reusing `require_actor()` (two messages); (3) audit growth bounded (false: `log_event` stores attacker-sized `x-correlation-id`). Also phone search vs E.164 broken, OR search unindexable, backfill untestable, multi-call create duplicates, relation RPCs race, useBlocker needs data router.
Action: all integrated into contract §6.3, §8-§12, §14 + TODO. Claims about key/role reach need proof via the auth admin API too, not only PostgREST grants.
## EVAL-036 | 2026-10-25 | V1-1.1 M1 workspaces: gates and isolated real stack
Method: fresh verifier on contract `.claude/tasks/contracts/2026-10-25-v1-1-1-workspaces.md` + fresh security auditor (semgrep 3 rulesets + hand SQL review), PGlite + sandbox runs, 5 mutations of M1 (email check, ON CONFLICT, correlation cap, foreign-member guard, service_role EXECUTE) all caught by 012.
Result: security PASS (2 MEDIUM scanner false positives: policy via helper, not raw auth.uid(); LOWs = table names in 42501, residual admin paths, NOT VALID CHECK, pre-existing bounded revoke reason). Verifier C1-C8 MET, C9 UNVERIFIABLE (forbidden to read DEV) → closed by `supabase migration list --local` (M1 remote empty).
Anomalies: first mutation run misread (sed indentation miss, crash not printed) → rerun with crash capture; concurrency script pipefail printed false "UNEXPECTED" after real ERROR → fixed. GoTrue 500 on same-email concurrent sign-up = GoTrue race on users_email_partial_key, not M1.
Action: contract for gates should name a read-only way to check DEV state (migration list) so C9-type clauses are verifiable.
+5
View File
@@ -400,3 +400,8 @@ R5.4: `draft/{labels,changelog,review_report,drawing,overlay,app_review,svg_comp
## 2026-10-25 (V1-1 ratification + preparation, branch feature/v1-1-clients-animals)
- Owner ratified V1-1 business decisions (BDR-073). Branch via gitflow lib off develop 5502617, pushed. Contract rewritten: approved §13.1, nomenclature §3, SQL M1-M3, RLS/helpers/RPCs §9, D15 thresholds §10, UI §11, tests §12, N1-N9 + D10-D14/D17/U1-U3 open, 6 steps in TODO.
- 3 challengers: CONCERNS, findings integrated (EVAL-035). Stop at checkpoint: no migration, no dependency, no Supabase DEV change.
## 2026-10-25 (V1-1.1 workspaces, branch feature/v1-1-clients-animals)
- Owner validated V1-1 architecture + N1-N9 (BDR-074; N4 voiding, N6 budget per workspace, N9 ids-only audit). Built M1 `20261025100000_workspaces.sql` + pgTAP 012 (85) + config test; commits 7bf4fb6 (code), 0f8c983 (docs).
- Isolated sandbox (DEV images, own net, loopback ports, no volume): fresh + upgrade paths, 531 pgTAP, concurrency, 33 HTTP checks; types generated there (sslmode=disable). DEV untouched (migration list: M1 local only).
- Gates: security PASS (0 HIGH), verifier ECARTS(1) = C9 unverifiable by it, closed by read-only migration list. rust:check + check:all green. STOP at checkpoint; M1 on DEV = owner action (SUPABASE.md §3.3).