docs(docs): R5.4 round 14 verdict, memory, TODO

This commit is contained in:
bchanot committed 2026-10-23 18:10:05 +02:00
1 parent eb667ada57
commit 637ea6334c
5 files changed
+26 -1

No files matched your search

+6
View File
@@ -211,3 +211,9 @@ Action: checkpoint R5.2 delivered, STOP before R5.3.
Method: check:all after each fix round; security-auditor (semgrep 725 rules, checklist) → PASS, 6 LOW (3 fixed: Map index, destination claimed + canonicalised, INIT_CWD absolute only); fresh verifier each round, no history. Pass 1 ECARTS(1) (floor on a plan heading) + 2 unreachable divergences aligned; pass 2 null-on-optional (LRN-072); pass 3 (first attempt died on API credit error, rerun on Opus) repeated keys refused by serde derive, NUL touch-mark silent drop (LRN-073), `--out symlink/` trailing slash followed the link; pass 4 C1-C12 met, C13 docs gaps (lossy UTF-8 read, 2 contrived splits undeclared, stale counts).
Anomalies: green byte parity on real data hid every finding: all were hostile-input or file-protection defects. A verdict reported after post-pass edits was not re-verified → owner required a fresh pass on the final state.
Action: refusal tests now compare reasons by stage; Object.prototype characterised + tested; migration-map debt characterised; final fresh verifier + security on the final R5.3 state before R5.4. Next ports: budget ≥3 verifier passes, probe hostile inputs (null, duplicates, reserved names, symlinks, encodings) in the oracle from the start.
## EVAL-029 | 2026-10-23 | R5.4 gates: 14 rounds (verifier + security + check:all) to converge
Method: each round fresh verifier (opus, contract from disk, own TS-vs-Rust differential) + fresh security-auditor (semgrep + checklist + memory probes) + `pnpm check:all`; superseded runs stopped. Rounds 1-5: Markdown guard families (denylist → allowlist at round 3); rounds 6-11: resource bounds (table amplification, records per op, string headers, drawings per annotation, fixed parts); 12-14: doc precision only. Final: c4e717d security PASS (LOW only), check:all green 16:41:34; eb667ad (docs/comments only over c4e717d) verifier all 9 clauses MET, ECARTS(13) = floor-guard hits on audit prose quoting suppression keywords (product paths clean).
Anomalies: docs repeatedly claimed bounds "before any row is built" / "tens of MB" that the next audit disproved; counts drifted after each fix; FLOOR family needs a contract Clarification (human gate), never an audit edit.
Action: LRN-074, LRN-075; checkpoint R5.4 to owner with decisions (FLOOR clarification, curation input cap vs 65× parse, bare URLs autolinked, 2 declared quadratic scans), STOP before R5.5.