chore(memory): contract — owner arbitrations Q1-Q4 and free ratio

This commit is contained in:
bchanot committed 2026-11-22 14:37:16 +01:00
1 parent c9317b8867
commit 4b8ac8cbb8
1 file changed
+2 -1
@@ -79,6 +79,7 @@ Présente-moi ton analyse, tes éventuels arbitrages et les maquettes avant de c
Q: UX and technical choices (crop vs clickable zone, annotations, zoom and pan, touch, accessibility, Undo/Redo and saving) / A: delegated by the owner (« Je te laisse autonome sur la solution UX et technique ») — the choices are made in the board's arbitrations and submitted with the mockups; none binds before the owner's graphic validation. Q: UX and technical choices (crop vs clickable zone, annotations, zoom and pan, touch, accessibility, Undo/Redo and saving) / A: delegated by the owner (« Je te laisse autonome sur la solution UX et technique ») — the choices are made in the board's arbitrations and submitted with the mockups; none binds before the owner's graphic validation.
Q: Phase / A: owner: mockups and the user journey first, analysis and arbitrations presented, no product code before the design agreement; then the usual process (plan, challenge, validation gate, subagent-driven implementation, verifier and security gates). Q: Phase / A: owner: mockups and the user journey first, analysis and arbitrations presented, no product code before the design agreement; then the usual process (plan, challenge, validation gate, subagent-driven implementation, verifier and security gates).
Q: Relation to the V1-2.6 UX plan / A: code fact (analysis 2026-11-22): the request maps onto plan step U4 « Detail view by rectangle (manual) » (docs/development/V1-2-6_UX_PLAN.md 616-631) and touches U6 (automatic access, internal category `cat-access`, BDR-101); the owner places it in U2 (« U2 reste ouvert pour cette nouvelle demande »). Board 08 (docs/design/v1-2-6/08-vue-detaillee-creation-desktop.png, validated 2026-11-05) is the prior reference. Q: Relation to the V1-2.6 UX plan / A: code fact (analysis 2026-11-22): the request maps onto plan step U4 « Detail view by rectangle (manual) » (docs/development/V1-2-6_UX_PLAN.md 616-631) and touches U6 (automatic access, internal category `cat-access`, BDR-101); the owner places it in U2 (« U2 reste ouvert pour cette nouvelle demande »). Board 08 (docs/design/v1-2-6/08-vue-detaillee-creation-desktop.png, validated 2026-11-05) is the prior reference.
Q: Owner arbitrations on Q1-Q4 + aspect ratio (2026-11-22, second message) / A: [gated 2026-11-22] Q1 option B: bring forward only the minimum of the U6 internal access category; present the consequences (schema, Rust, SQL) before any such change. Q2 overlap allowed: annotations keep click/touch priority, the access must stay reachable even when heavily covered. Q3 new view starts empty, annotations stay on their view, any copy handled in U5; fix the contradictory caption of validated board 08. Q4 keep free-form accesses: create and edit rectangle, polygon and circle accesses; crop rectangle and access are distinct; an access may be generated at view creation then reshaped (like the head); avoid a fifth permanent button. 4:3 not validated: study free-ratio crops and their consistency in editor, bilan and PDF. Update analysis, arbitrations and mockups; final panels at readable size before graphic validation; then the implementation plan.
## ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA ## ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA
Phase 1 (this run, before any product code): Phase 1 (this run, before any product code):
@@ -92,5 +93,5 @@ Phase 1 (this run, before any product code):
Phase 2 criteria are appended, tagged [gated <date>], after the owner's design approval. Phase 2 criteria are appended, tagged [gated <date>], after the owner's design approval.
## FILE SCOPE ## FILE SCOPE
Phase 1: docs/design/v1-2-6-u2-detail-views/ (new), docs/design/README.md (index line), .claude/tasks/ (contract, plan). Phase 1: docs/design/v1-2-6-u2-detail-views/ (new), docs/design/README.md (index line), docs/design/v1-2-6/maquettes.html and 08-vue-detaillee-creation-desktop.png (board 08 caption fix, owner 2026-11-22 [gated]), .claude/tasks/ (contract, plan).
Phase 2 (after approval, to be fixed by the plan): apps/app/src/components/editor/{annotations,views}/, apps/app/src/editor/{annotations,state}/, apps/app/src/i18n/{fr,en}.ts, apps/app/src/components/canvas/ (bilan modal), apps/app/src/components/catalogue/, tests (unit, e2e/shell), docs/ANNOTATION-RENDERING.md, docs/development/V1-2-6_*.md; crates/core only if a rule or query must move to Rust (BDR-043). Phase 2 (after approval, to be fixed by the plan): apps/app/src/components/editor/{annotations,views}/, apps/app/src/editor/{annotations,state}/, apps/app/src/i18n/{fr,en}.ts, apps/app/src/components/canvas/ (bilan modal), apps/app/src/components/catalogue/, tests (unit, e2e/shell), docs/ANNOTATION-RENDERING.md, docs/development/V1-2-6_*.md; crates/core only if a rule or query must move to Rust (BDR-043).