docs(docs): R4 close: J1/J2 results as declared (real iPhone Safari iOS, missing details listed), RUST.md §10.15 residual risks and final checks, PDF_IMPORT_HARDENING.md §7, CHANGELOG headers, TODO R4.13, BDR-067

This commit is contained in:
bchanot committed 2026-10-21 22:23:32 +02:00
1 parent 22bbfb4c8b
commit 3a7937e9fb
8 files changed
+174 -44

No files matched your search

+34 -16
View File
@@ -13,26 +13,34 @@ a simulator never fills its column and is never a memory proof). The
result per check was declared without the split per browser: it
sits in the last column. Every device cell stays `NON TESTÉ`. Brave is
outside the OD-6 list, reported as run.
Status 2026-10-21 (R4 close): the owner ran J2 on a real iPhone with
Safari iOS and reports it as passed as a whole, with no blocking anomaly;
J2.3 passes under the corrected rule (a new export carries the
application's current branding). The declaration covers the recette, not
each check: the iPhone column carries it as `PASS déclaré` per row; the
model, the versions, the surface, the J2.6 time and the memory
observations of J2.6 and J2.7 were not given and are not inferred.
| Device, browser, version | Surface (1 dev / 2 prod CSP) | Date |
|---|---|---|
| (to be given by the owner) | | |
| iPhone, Safari iOS (model and versions not given) | not given | 2026-10-21 |
| Check | Computer, Chrome | Computer, Firefox | Computer, Brave (outside OD-6) | iPhone, Safari iOS (not run) | Android, its browser | Declared 2026-10-21, no browser split |
| Check | Computer, Chrome | Computer, Firefox | Computer, Brave (outside OD-6) | iPhone, Safari iOS (run 2026-10-21, declared as a whole) | Android, its browser | Declared 2026-10-21, no browser split |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| J2.1 FR export identical to the imported demo | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.2 EN export | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.3 export of an archive without logos | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | acceptable under the corrected expected result, subject to the logos matching the current branding (owner, 2026-10-21; option 1 final, corrected expected result validated) |
| J2.4 links open the three sites | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.5 real rasters crisp at 400 % | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.6 L export on the phone (E4), time, tab alive | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.7 six demo exports in a row | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.8 round trip of an exported file | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.9 interrupted export | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.10 engine unavailable then recovered | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.1 FR export identical to the imported demo | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.2 EN export | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.3 export of an archive without logos | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré under the corrected rule | NON TESTÉ | PASS under the corrected expected result (owner, 2026-10-21: option 1 final, a new export carries the current Faunosteo branding) |
| J2.4 links open the three sites | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.5 real rasters crisp at 400 % | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.6 L export on the phone (E4), time, tab alive | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré, no time or memory observation given | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.7 six demo exports in a row | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré, no memory observation given | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.8 round trip of an exported file | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.9 interrupted export | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.10 engine unavailable then recovered | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.11 CAP export (computer only) | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | not applicable | not applicable | PASS déclaré |
| J2.12 views and markers of an observation | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.13 attachment listed, properties Faunosteo | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.12 views and markers of an observation | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.13 attachment listed, properties Faunosteo | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré | NON TESTÉ | PASS déclaré |
| J2.14 `pnpm report:compare` (computer only) | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | NON TESTÉ | not applicable | not applicable | PASS déclaré |
Notes (FAIL, incidents, timings, memory warnings, reloads):
@@ -45,7 +53,17 @@ Notes (FAIL, incidents, timings, memory warnings, reloads):
the rule stays, the expected result of J2.3 is corrected (R4_J2.md), and
the observed result is acceptable under it, subject to the logos shown
being the application's current branding (the four logos of J2.1). No
engine, golden or oracle change.
engine, golden or oracle change. Owner, 2026-10-21 (R4 close): J2.3 PASS
under the approved rule.
- iPhone, Safari iOS (owner, 2026-10-21): J2 reported as passed as a
whole, no blocking anomaly. Missing for the per-check justification the
grid asks for, not invented: the iPhone model, the iOS and Safari
versions, the surface, the J2.6 time to the download and whether the tab
survived, the memory observations of J2.6 and J2.7 (reloads, warnings).
Item 7 of `PDF_IMPORT_HARDENING.md` §6 (per-export growth) stays
accepted temporarily for that reason (§7 there).
Recommendation (filled after the run): accept R4.6 as is / accept with
follow-ups / do not accept, and why.
Recommendation (owner, 2026-10-21): accept with follow-ups. R4.6 is
accepted on the computer (Chrome, Firefox, Brave), Android and the real
iPhone, J2.3 under the corrected rule; the follow-ups are the device
timings and memory observations not reported.