fix(anatomy): prescan closers searched after their opener; ASCII-only href trim; root painting attributes removed (security audit R3)

This commit is contained in:
bchanot committed 2026-10-15 00:25:43 +02:00
1 parent d3d63394dd
commit 157c854ed1
13 files changed
+3231 -21

No files matched your search

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><g><![CDATA[]]><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></g></svg>

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 555 B

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><!--></svg><![CDATA[--><path a0="0" a1="1" a2="2" a3="3" a4="4" a5="5" a6="6" a7="7" a8="8" a9="9" a10="10" a11="11" a12="12" a13="13" a14="14" a15="15" a16="16" a17="17" a18="18" a19="19" a20="20" a21="21" a22="22" a23="23" a24="24" a25="25" a26="26" a27="27" a28="28" a29="29" a30="30" a31="31" a32="32" a33="33" a34="34" a35="35" a36="36" a37="37" a38="38" a39="39" a40="40" a41="41" a42="42" a43="43" a44="44" a45="45" a46="46" a47="47" a48="48" a49="49" a50="50" a51="51" a52="52" a53="53" a54="54" a55="55" a56="56" a57="57" a58="58" a59="59" a60="60" a61="61" a62="62" a63="63" a64="64" a65="65" a66="66" a67="67" a68="68" a69="69" a70="70" a71="71" a72="72" a73="73" a74="74" a75="75" a76="76" a77="77" a78="78" a79="79" a80="80" a81="81" a82="82" a83="83" a84="84" a85="85" a86="86" a87="87" a88="88" a89="89" a90="90" a91="91" a92="92" a93="93" a94="94" a95="95" a96="96" a97="97" a98="98" a99="99" a100="100" a101="101" a102="102" a103="103" a104="104" a105="105" a106="106" a107="107" a108="108" a109="109" a110="110" a111="111" a112="112" a113="113" a114="114" a115="115" a116="116" a117="117" a118="118" a119="119" a120="120" a121="121" a122="122" a123="123" a124="124" a125="125" a126="126" a127="127" a128="128" a129="129" a130="130" a131="131" a132="132" a133="133" a134="134" a135="135" a136="136" a137="137" a138="138" a139="139" a140="140" a141="141" a142="142" a143="143" a144="144" a145="145" a146="146" a147="147" a148="148" a149="149" a150="150" a151="151" a152="152" a153="153" a154="154" a155="155" a156="156" a157="157" a158="158" a159="159" a160="160" a161="161" a162="162" a163="163" a164="164" a165="165" a166="166" a167="167" a168="168" a169="169" a170="170" a171="171" a172="172" a173="173" a174="174" a175="175" a176="176" a177="177" a178="178" a179="179" a180="180" a181="181" a182="182" a183="183" a184="184" a185="185" a186="186" a187="187" a188="188" a189="189" a190="190" a191="191" a192="192" a193="193" a194="194" a195="195" a196="196" a197="197" a198="198" a199="199" a200="200" a201="201" a202="202" a203="203" a204="204" a205="205" a206="206" a207="207" a208="208" a209="209" a210="210" a211="211" a212="212" a213="213" a214="214" a215="215" a216="216" a217="217" a218="218" a219="219" a220="220" a221="221" a222="222" a223="223" a224="224" a225="225" a226="226" a227="227" a228="228" a229="229" a230="230" a231="231" a232="232" a233="233" a234="234" a235="235" a236="236" a237="237" a238="238" a239="239" a240="240" a241="241" a242="242" a243="243" a244="244" a245="245" a246="246" a247="247" a248="248" a249="249" a250="250" a251="251" a252="252" a253="253" a254="254" a255="255" a256="256" a257="257" a258="258" a259="259" a260="260" a261="261" a262="262" a263="263" a264="264" a265="265" a266="266" a267="267" a268="268" a269="269" a270="270" a271="271" a272="272" a273="273" a274="274" a275="275" a276="276" a277="277" a278="278" a279="279" a280="280" a281="281" a282="282" a283="283" a284="284" a285="285" a286="286" a287="287" a288="288" a289="289" a290="290" a291="291" a292="292" a293="293" a294="294" a295="295" a296="296" a297="297" a298="298" a299="299" a300="300" a301="301" a302="302" a303="303" a304="304" a305="305" a306="306" a307="307" a308="308" a309="309" a310="310" a311="311" a312="312" a313="313" a314="314" a315="315" a316="316" a317="317" a318="318" a319="319" a320="320" a321="321" a322="322" a323="323" a324="324" a325="325" a326="326" a327="327" a328="328" a329="329" a330="330" a331="331" a332="332" a333="333" a334="334" a335="335" a336="336" a337="337" a338="338" a339="339" a340="340" a341="341" a342="342" a343="343" a344="344" a345="345" a346="346" a347="347" a348="348" a349="349" a350="350" a351="351" a352="352" a353="353" a354="354" a355="355" a356="356" a357="357" a358="358" a359="359" a360="360" a361="361" a362="362" a363="363" a364="364" a365="365" a366="366" a367="367" a368="368" a369="369" a370="370" a371="371" a372="372" a373="373" a374="374" a375="375" a376="376" a377="377" a378="378" a379="379" a380="380" a381="381" a382="382" a383="383" a384="384" a385="385" a386="386" a387="387" a388="388" a389="389" a390="390" a391="391" a392="392" a393="393" a394="394" a395="395" a396="396" a397="397" a398="398" a399="399" a400="400" a401="401" a402="402" a403="403" a404="404" a405="405" a406="406" a407="407" a408="408" a409="409" a410="410" a411="411" a412="412" a413="413" a414="414" a415="415" a416="416" a417="417" a418="418" a419="419" a420="420" a421="421" a422="422" a423="423" a424="424" a425="425" a426="426" a427="427" a428="428" a429="429" a430="430" a431="431" a432="432" a433="433" a434="434" a435="435" a436="436" a437="437" a438="438" a439="439" a440="440" a441="441" a442="442" a443="443" a444="444" a445="445" a446="446" a447="447" a448="448" a449="449" a450="450" a451="451" a452="452" a453="453" a454="454" a455="455" a456="456" a457="457" a458="458" a459="459" a460="460" a461="461" a462="462" a463="463" a464="464" a465="465" a466="466" a467="467" a4Line truncated

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 36 KiB

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg"><!--></svg><![CDATA[--><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><g><Line truncated

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 34 KiB

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink"><path id="a" d="M0 0h1"/><use href=" #a"/><use xlink:href="#a"/><use href=" #a "/></svg>

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 175 B

@@ -0,0 +1 @@
<svg xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg" transform="scale(40)" filter="url(#f)" mask="url(#m)" clip-path="url(#c)"><filter id="f"/><mask id="m"/><clipPath id="c"/><path d="M0 0h1"/></svg>

After

Width:  |  Height:  |  Size: 186 B

File diff suppressed because it is too large. Load diff
+34 -3
View File
@@ -8,7 +8,8 @@
//! children with text; the Rust tree is the reader's output serialised and read again. The
//! declared rules that change a tree (comments and PIs dropped, text only in `title`/`desc`,
//! elements outside the SVG namespace removed, ids outside the reference grammar removed, no
//! `class`/`style` on the root) are applied to the TS tree before comparing.
//! `class`/`style`/`transform`/`filter`/`mask`/`clip-path` on the root) are applied to the TS
//! tree before comparing.
#![allow(clippy::disallowed_methods, clippy::unwrap_used, clippy::expect_used)]
mod common;
@@ -37,6 +38,16 @@ fn declared(file: &str) -> Option<Value> {
// C3 namespace: `xlink:href` whose prefix is bound to another URI is removed.
"xlink-prefix-rebound.svg" => json!({ "removed": ["linearGradient@xlink:href"],
"strip": [["linearGradient", "xlink:href"]] }),
// C3 references: an href is local only as the URL parser reads it (ASCII whitespace
// stripped, nothing else); the TS trimmed JavaScript spaces (security audit R3).
"href-unicode-space.svg" => json!({ "removed": ["use@href", "use@xlink:href"],
"strip_unicode_spaced_refs": true }),
// C3 root: nothing that paints outside the box on the inline root (security audit R3).
"root-presentation.svg" => {
json!({ "removed": ["svg@transform", "svg@filter", "svg@mask", "svg@clip-path"] })
}
// C2: the prescan's per-element attribute cap (TS removes the 3,000 data-like names).
"comment-desync-attributes.svg" => json!({ "rejected": "too_complex" }),
// C3 root: no class or style on the inline root.
"root-class-style.svg" => json!({ "removed": ["svg@class", "svg@style"] }),
_ => return None,
@@ -67,6 +78,22 @@ fn strip(tree: &mut Value, element: &str, attribute: &str) {
}
}
/// Removes `href`/`xlink:href` values that start with a non-ASCII character (a declared removal).
fn strip_unicode_spaced_refs(tree: &mut Value) {
if let Some(attrs) = tree["attrs"].as_object_mut() {
attrs.retain(|name, value| {
let spaced = value
.as_str()
.and_then(|v| v.chars().next())
.is_some_and(|c| !c.is_ascii());
!((name == "href" || name == "xlink:href") && spaced)
});
}
if let Some(children) = tree["children"].as_array_mut() {
children.iter_mut().for_each(strip_unicode_spaced_refs);
}
}
fn is_space(text: &str) -> bool {
text.chars().all(|c| matches!(c, ' ' | '\t' | '\n' | '\r'))
}
@@ -92,8 +119,9 @@ fn declared_tree(node: &Value, keeps_text: bool, root: bool) -> Option<Value> {
attrs.remove("id");
}
if root {
attrs.remove("class");
attrs.remove("style");
for name in ["class", "style", "transform", "filter", "mask", "clip-path"] {
attrs.remove(name);
}
}
let text_inside = matches!(name, "title" | "desc");
let children: Vec<Value> = node["children"]
@@ -127,6 +155,9 @@ fn every_hostile_case_gives_the_typescript_verdict_or_a_declared_one() {
Some(expected) => {
assert_eq!(rust["removed"], expected["removed"], "{file}");
let mut tree = declared_tree(&ts["tree"], false, true).unwrap();
if expected["strip_unicode_spaced_refs"] == true {
strip_unicode_spaced_refs(&mut tree);
}
for pair in expected["strip"].as_array().into_iter().flatten() {
strip(
&mut tree,