docs(docs): owner validates criterion 32 on db:trial

This commit is contained in:
bchanot committed 2026-11-22 01:15:49 +01:00
1 parent 8537a98bea
commit 04ec232613
2 files changed
+5 -1

No files matched your search

+4
View File
@@ -875,6 +875,10 @@ Tablette en paysage (au moins 1 024 px de large ; en dessous, l'éditeur est en
suppression est immédiate dans le brouillon, à enregistrer ensuite). « Défaire » annule la dernière modification, suppression est immédiate dans le brouillon, à enregistrer ensuite). « Défaire » annule la dernière modification,
suppression comprise : il rend la vue supprimée. suppression comprise : il rend la vue supprimée.
**Résultat (2026-11-22)** : rangée des vues (critère 32) essayée par le propriétaire sur `db:trial` à la souris (A1 à
A6), au clavier (B1 à B6), sur tablette et téléphone (C1 à C8), stabilité et nettoyage (D1 à D4) : tout conforme. Les
six vues temporaires ont été supprimées et la fiche enregistrée. Critère 32 validé définitivement ; U2 reste ouvert.
#### Acceptés pendant la construction #### Acceptés pendant la construction
Vous avez accepté ces cinq comportements ; ils ne sont plus à juger : Vous avez accepté ces cinq comportements ; ils ne sont plus à juger :
- Échap pendant un nouveau tracé demande d'abord « Abandonner la création ? ». - Échap pendant un nouveau tracé demande d'abord « Abandonner la création ? ».
+1 -1
View File
@@ -66,7 +66,7 @@ Implemented (plan `.claude/tasks/plans/2026-11-17-v1-2-6-u2.md`, rev 4 then rev
| Open-side bubble (« − ») | unit (`annotations.removeBubble.test.ts`): sweep over the six equine polygons of the main view at zoom 1 to 6, clear of every shown « + » and of its own vertex, inside the frame; a control showing the former centre fails the criterion (thoracic, vertex 2); the part on screen when zoomed and panned, an off-screen vertex not forced, a vertex rung kept clear of another vertex on the open ray. E2E touch (`editor-touch.spec.ts`): on « Vertèbres thoraciques » zoomed, every chosen vertex keeps its bubble clear, on screen and light; a tap on « + » adds, « Défaire » restores | | Open-side bubble (« − ») | unit (`annotations.removeBubble.test.ts`): sweep over the six equine polygons of the main view at zoom 1 to 6, clear of every shown « + » and of its own vertex, inside the frame; a control showing the former centre fails the criterion (thoracic, vertex 2); the part on screen when zoomed and panned, an off-screen vertex not forced, a vertex rung kept clear of another vertex on the open ray. E2E touch (`editor-touch.spec.ts`): on « Vertèbres thoraciques » zoomed, every chosen vertex keeps its bubble clear, on screen and light; a tap on « + » adds, « Défaire » restores |
| Device-independent geometry (criterion 8) | `annotations.pointSize.test.ts` and the `insertMidpoint` tests of `annotations.polygonEdit.test.ts`; the handle sizes are read only by `HandleLayer` and `ZoneHandles` | | Device-independent geometry (criterion 8) | `annotations.pointSize.test.ts` and the `insertMidpoint` tests of `annotations.polygonEdit.test.ts`; the handle sizes are read only by `HandleLayer` and `ZoneHandles` |
| Criterion 32 on the final code (Task 7 Step 4b), 2026-11-20, superseded by the three rows below | with eight long-named detail views the chips take 3 to 5 rows and the stuck column overflows the window bottom. Measured overflow: 1 024 × 768, 5 rows, 64.3 px; 1 180 × 820, 3 rows, 53.3 px; 1 180 × 700, 3 rows, 76.0 px; 1 280 × 800, 5 rows, 24.3 px. The canvas size and the absence of sideways scroll hold; near the page end the column top also rises above the strip bottom. The test is committed as `test.fixme` in `editor-geometry.spec.ts` (« owner decision pending (criterion 32, chips on several rows) »). The pinned budget has counted ONE row of chips since Task 17 (pre-existing: at 1 280 px the add row did not change and still overflows 24.3 px). With one row (the equine sheet) the whole `editor-geometry.spec.ts` passes, short windows included. Decision pending: the budget for chips on several rows (options: raise the pinned budget per chip row (measured), let the chips scroll in one row, or accept the limit) | | Criterion 32 on the final code (Task 7 Step 4b), 2026-11-20, superseded by the three rows below | with eight long-named detail views the chips take 3 to 5 rows and the stuck column overflows the window bottom. Measured overflow: 1 024 × 768, 5 rows, 64.3 px; 1 180 × 820, 3 rows, 53.3 px; 1 180 × 700, 3 rows, 76.0 px; 1 280 × 800, 5 rows, 24.3 px. The canvas size and the absence of sideways scroll hold; near the page end the column top also rises above the strip bottom. The test is committed as `test.fixme` in `editor-geometry.spec.ts` (« owner decision pending (criterion 32, chips on several rows) »). The pinned budget has counted ONE row of chips since Task 17 (pre-existing: at 1 280 px the add row did not change and still overflows 24.3 px). With one row (the equine sheet) the whole `editor-geometry.spec.ts` passes, short windows included. Decision pending: the budget for chips on several rows (options: raise the pinned budget per chip row (measured), let the chips scroll in one row, or accept the limit) |
| Criterion 32 with one scrolling row (2026-11-21, board `v1-2-6-u2-chips/`, owner tablet check pending) | the chips sit in one horizontally scrolling row: it scrolls with a finger, a Shift + wheel, a tilt wheel or a trackpad horizontal scroll (« wheel » below means these: a plain vertical wheel does not move a horizontal row); the criterion 32 test in `editor-geometry.spec.ts` (`test.fixme` removed) passes at 1 024 × 768, 1 180 × 820, 1 180 × 700 and 1 280 × 800 with eight long-named views: one chip top, the row overflows inside itself (`scrollWidth > clientWidth`), the scroll walk green. The real DOM parts, read back at 1 180 × 820 and 1 280 × 800, are 162 px and 154 px, equal to the CSS budget (10.125rem and 9.625rem). Run: dated pass at HEAD 7d6f7cb2 (2026-11-21 22:58-23:07, `--workers=2`, clean tree): editor-geometry 62, editor-drawings 3, editor-shell-layout 13, editor-access 9, editor-shell-crossing 12, editor-touch 15, editor-annotations 23, editor-zones 5, editor-deselect 10, editor-journey 1 passed, 0 failed; unit app 2 238 passed; full shell suite at b510bf9c (2026-11-21 23:39 to 2026-11-22 00:08, the 33 baseline specs by full path, never `editor-equine.spec.ts`, `--workers=2`): 381 passed, 268 skipped, 13 failed (29.3 min), the 13 failures being exactly the 13 environment failures of the 3d6aacad baseline by test name, none new. | | Criterion 32 with one scrolling row (2026-11-21, board `v1-2-6-u2-chips/`, validated by the owner on `db:trial` 2026-11-22: mouse, keyboard, tablet and phone, stability and clean-up all OK) | the chips sit in one horizontally scrolling row: it scrolls with a finger, a Shift + wheel, a tilt wheel or a trackpad horizontal scroll (« wheel » below means these: a plain vertical wheel does not move a horizontal row); the criterion 32 test in `editor-geometry.spec.ts` (`test.fixme` removed) passes at 1 024 × 768, 1 180 × 820, 1 180 × 700 and 1 280 × 800 with eight long-named views: one chip top, the row overflows inside itself (`scrollWidth > clientWidth`), the scroll walk green. The real DOM parts, read back at 1 180 × 820 and 1 280 × 800, are 162 px and 154 px, equal to the CSS budget (10.125rem and 9.625rem). Run: dated pass at HEAD 7d6f7cb2 (2026-11-21 22:58-23:07, `--workers=2`, clean tree): editor-geometry 62, editor-drawings 3, editor-shell-layout 13, editor-access 9, editor-shell-crossing 12, editor-touch 15, editor-annotations 23, editor-zones 5, editor-deselect 10, editor-journey 1 passed, 0 failed; unit app 2 238 passed; full shell suite at b510bf9c (2026-11-21 23:39 to 2026-11-22 00:08, the 33 baseline specs by full path, never `editor-equine.spec.ts`, `--workers=2`): 381 passed, 268 skipped, 13 failed (29.3 min), the 13 failures being exactly the 13 environment failures of the 3d6aacad baseline by test name, none new. |
| View row tests (2026-11-21) | unit `annotations.viewRow.test.ts` (reveal, hint state) and `editor-view-row.test.tsx`: a guarded view change refused with « Continuer » leaves the active view and `aria-pressed` unchanged and runs no activation reveal; the row is revealed again on the active chip when the hidden edit body is shown again; a language switch with long names recomputes the hints; a removed view whose chip had focus leaves a tab stop; a keyboard focus entering a chip from outside the row (`:focus-visible`) reveals it, a pointer focus never does. A reveal is judged against where a slide in flight lands (a reversed arrow, an arrow after a chevron page), and a repeated click (`detail` above 1) on a chip is ignored. E2E (`editor-geometry.spec.ts`, `editor-shell-layout.spec.ts`): the view row at 1 024 × 768, on a phone (375), under the sticky strip, read-only (reviewer, 1 280 × 800), a pointer press on a peeking chip activates it at the first click without scrolling the row, a swipe starting on a chip activates nothing, language switch en to fr | | View row tests (2026-11-21) | unit `annotations.viewRow.test.ts` (reveal, hint state) and `editor-view-row.test.tsx`: a guarded view change refused with « Continuer » leaves the active view and `aria-pressed` unchanged and runs no activation reveal; the row is revealed again on the active chip when the hidden edit body is shown again; a language switch with long names recomputes the hints; a removed view whose chip had focus leaves a tab stop; a keyboard focus entering a chip from outside the row (`:focus-visible`) reveals it, a pointer focus never does. A reveal is judged against where a slide in flight lands (a reversed arrow, an arrow after a chevron page), and a repeated click (`detail` above 1) on a chip is ignored. E2E (`editor-geometry.spec.ts`, `editor-shell-layout.spec.ts`): the view row at 1 024 × 768, on a phone (375), under the sticky strip, read-only (reviewer, 1 280 × 800), a pointer press on a peeking chip activates it at the first click without scrolling the row, a swipe starting on a chip activates nothing, language switch en to fr |
| Residual risks (one scrolling row; the three residuals owner-accepted 2026-11-21, the two rulings below, accepted by the owner 2026-11-21) | a row scroll closes an open « Défaire / Refaire » hold bubble (closed by any scroll, owner rule kept 2026-11-20); the chevron hit areas are a swipe dead zone at the row ends; some focus behaviours are proven only in Chromium (Tab entry clear of the fades relies on `scroll-padding-inline` plus the `:focus-visible` reveal). Test scope (controller ruling during execution, accepted by the owner 2026-11-21): the language-switch vertical check is measured below the draft header, which wraps per language; the read-only twin's shown-again placement is checked with the properties dialog open; touch fling and inertia, a drag starting under a chevron and pinch-zoom are left for the owner's tablet trial. Deviation from plan rev 3 (controller ruling during execution, accepted by the owner 2026-11-21): `scroll-padding-inline` alone left a chip partly under the end fade on Tab entry, so a chip receiving keyboard focus from outside the row is revealed; a pointer focus never reveals, so the row never scrolls at a press | | Residual risks (one scrolling row; the three residuals owner-accepted 2026-11-21, the two rulings below, accepted by the owner 2026-11-21) | a row scroll closes an open « Défaire / Refaire » hold bubble (closed by any scroll, owner rule kept 2026-11-20); the chevron hit areas are a swipe dead zone at the row ends; some focus behaviours are proven only in Chromium (Tab entry clear of the fades relies on `scroll-padding-inline` plus the `:focus-visible` reveal). Test scope (controller ruling during execution, accepted by the owner 2026-11-21): the language-switch vertical check is measured below the draft header, which wraps per language; the read-only twin's shown-again placement is checked with the properties dialog open; touch fling and inertia, a drag starting under a chevron and pinch-zoom are left for the owner's tablet trial. Deviation from plan rev 3 (controller ruling during execution, accepted by the owner 2026-11-21): `scroll-padding-inline` alone left a chip partly under the end fade on Tab entry, so a chip receiving keyboard focus from outside the row is revealed; a pointer focus never reveals, so the row never scrolls at a press |
| Residual risks (trial adjustments) | assistive technologies activating with `detail ≥ 1` arm the tool instead of placing at the centre (mitigated 2026-11-21 by « Placer au centre » in the add row (works whatever the activation)); a fast double tap on the tablet browser: counted as a double-click (stays armed) or as two taps (arms then disarms), not verified on the device; the canvas box can be scrolled by a focus (overflow-hidden), the bubble's screen bound then lags (pre-existing, pointer choices use `preventScroll`) | | Residual risks (trial adjustments) | assistive technologies activating with `detail ≥ 1` arm the tool instead of placing at the centre (mitigated 2026-11-21 by « Placer au centre » in the add row (works whatever the activation)); a fast double tap on the tablet browser: counted as a double-click (stays armed) or as two taps (arms then disarms), not verified on the device; the canvas box can be scrolled by a focus (overflow-hidden), the bubble's screen bound then lags (pre-existing, pointer choices use `preventScroll`) |