From 79f1a3fc2c005bcbf9ff135da3c4418fc17f0a57 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: bchanot Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 14:27:59 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 1/4] test(push-guard): forgive the 6 dead deny entries, lock still bites T41 drops the dead Write lines and requires the working Bash forms. T42 forgives the 2 dead Bash entries main carries until version.txt passes 3.0.0; T42c/T42d/T42e prove the lock, the planned hand edit and the expiry. --- lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh | 50 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++------ 1 file changed, 42 insertions(+), 8 deletions(-) diff --git a/lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh b/lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh index 50c0bb8..54383a3 100644 --- a/lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh +++ b/lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh @@ -298,6 +298,9 @@ check T40-wiring "$(jq -e '.hooks.PreToolUse[] | select(any(.hooks[]; .command=="bash ~/.claude/hooks/push-guard.sh")) | .matcher=="Bash|Monitor" and .hooks[0].timeout==10' "$S" 2>&1)" true +# Write twins of the 4 Edit lines dropped 2026-11-12: a Write(glob) deny never +# blocks the Write tool, the Edit form does. The 2 Bash lines guard the +# working forms. has_deny() { jq -e --arg e "$1" '.permissions.deny | index($e)' "$S" >/dev/null; } missing="" while IFS= read -r e; do @@ -314,18 +317,34 @@ Bash(*GIT_CONFIG_COUNT*) Bash(* GIT_CONFIG_GLOBAL=*) Bash(* GIT_CONFIG_SYSTEM=*) Edit(**/.git/config) -Write(**/.git/config) Edit(**/.gitconfig) -Write(**/.gitconfig) Edit(~/.gitconfig) -Write(~/.gitconfig) Edit(~/.config/git/config) -Write(~/.config/git/config) +Bash(docker run * -v /:/*) +Bash(git push * :**) EOF check T41-new-deny-present "$missing" "" +# Deny entries of the last release dropped on purpose, forgiven by T42 until +# version.txt passes removed_ok_until (T42e): empty the list in that bump. +removed_ok_until=3.0.0 +grep -v '^#' > "$WORK/removed-ok" <<'EOF' +# mixed `* -v /:*` form never matches; `-v /:/*` kept (2026-10-23) +Bash(docker run * -v /:*) +# mixed `* :*` form never matches; ` :**` kept (2026-10-23) +Bash(git push * :*) +EOF +cur=$(tr -d '[:space:]' < "$ROOT/version.txt") +expired="" +[ -n "$cur" ] || expired="version.txt unreadable" +if [ -s "$WORK/removed-ok" ] && [ "$cur" != "$removed_ok_until" ] && + [ "$(printf '%s\n' "$removed_ok_until" "$cur" | sort -V | tail -1)" = "$cur" ] +then expired=$(tr '\n' ' ' < "$WORK/removed-ok"); fi +check T42e-list-not-expired "$expired" "" + # Nothing removed: every deny entry of the fresher of origin/main and main -# (the last release) is still there. Neither ref resolves: SKIP, no count. +# (the last release) is still there, except the justified list above. +# Neither ref resolves: SKIP, no count. rv() { git -C "$ROOT" rev-parse -q --verify "$1" >/dev/null 2>&1; } base="" if rv origin/main && rv main; then @@ -334,6 +353,12 @@ if rv origin/main && rv main; then elif rv origin/main; then base=origin/main elif rv main; then base=main fi +deny_lost() { # : base deny entries missing, minus the list + git -C "$ROOT" show "$base:settings.json" 2>/dev/null \ + | jq -r --slurpfile now "$1" '.permissions.deny[] + | select(. as $e | ($now[0].permissions.deny | index($e)) == null)' \ + | grep -vxF -f "$WORK/removed-ok" +} if [ -z "$base" ]; then echo "SKIP T42 (no main ref)" else @@ -341,10 +366,19 @@ else basedeny=$(git -C "$ROOT" show "$base:settings.json" 2>/dev/null \ | jq -r '.permissions.deny[]' 2>/dev/null) check T42-base-nonempty "$([ -n "$basedeny" ] && echo yes || echo no)" yes - lost=$(git -C "$ROOT" show "$base:settings.json" 2>/dev/null \ - | jq -r --slurpfile now "$S" \ - '.permissions.deny[] | select(. as $e | ($now[0].permissions.deny | index($e)) == null)') + lost=$(deny_lost "$S") check T42-nothing-removed "$lost" "" + # T42c: the lock still bites on an entry that is not in the list + probe=$(printf '%s\n' "$basedeny" | grep -vxF -f "$WORK/removed-ok" | head -1) + jq --arg e "$probe" '.permissions.deny -= [$e]' "$S" > "$WORK/s-probe.json" + check T42c-lock-bites \ + "$(deny_lost "$WORK/s-probe.json" | grep -cxF -- "$probe")" 1 + # T42d: the user's hand edit (the 6 dead entries out) is forgiven + jq '.permissions.deny -= ["Bash(docker run * -v /:*)", + "Bash(git push * :*)", "Write(**/.git/config)", "Write(**/.gitconfig)", + "Write(~/.gitconfig)", "Write(~/.config/git/config)"]' "$S" \ + > "$WORK/s-after.json" + check T42d-edit-forgiven "$(deny_lost "$WORK/s-after.json")" "" fi soft=$(jq -r '.autoMode.soft_deny[]' "$S") From 72ae6084da5841c733a9f2017a42b09e0bc74e65 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: bchanot Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 14:30:29 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 2/4] chore(memory): dead-deny lock done, BDR-145, LRN-280, hand edit queued --- .claude/memory/decisions.md | 6 + .claude/memory/journal.md | 1 + .claude/memory/learnings.md | 6 + .claude/tasks/TODO.md | 3 +- .../2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md | 36 ++++++ .../plans/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md | 117 ++++++++++++++++++ 6 files changed, 168 insertions(+), 1 deletion(-) create mode 100644 .claude/tasks/contracts/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md create mode 100644 .claude/tasks/plans/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md diff --git a/.claude/memory/decisions.md b/.claude/memory/decisions.md index 63dd417..df09afb 100644 --- a/.claude/memory/decisions.md +++ b/.claude/memory/decisions.md @@ -1548,3 +1548,9 @@ Supersedes [[BDR-030]]. - **Decision**: read `.claude/tasks/TODO.md` + apply banner `memory digest` (open BLK, last journal); `+N` count line -> read those BLK in blockers.md; no digest (foreign repo, memory mod off) -> list open BLK by hand. Registries read when task needs; planning flows scan per `lib/analyze-before-plan.md`. capitalize closing line aligned. User gated 2026-11-12 (2 re-gates after challenge). - **Alternatives**: digest only (rejected: `_digest_todo` reads only `### Actionable`, init-project/onboard TODOs lack it -> TODO unread in other projects); full 5-registry read each start (rejected: 78-357 KB files, cost 4a/4c removed). - **Consequences**: D1b follow-up makes every project TODO digest-readable. Commit c69ce9c. + +## BDR-145 — Released deny removal via justified T42 list expiring by version [accepted] (2026-11-12) +- **Context**: 6 dead deny entries in settings.json (2 mixed Bash forms never match, 4 Write(glob) never block Write) kept alive by push-guard T41/T42 non-weakening lock (BDR-111). User removes them by hand; test must stay green before and after. +- **Decision**: removal of a released deny entry goes through a justified list in push-guard T42 (exact rows, `#` reason line each), forgiven until `removed_ok_until` (=3.0.0); T42e fails once version.txt passes it while list non-empty, list emptied in that bump. T42c proves unlisted removal still fails, T42d simulates exact hand edit. Write twins never shipped -> just leave T41. User gated 2026-11-12 (2 re-gates). +- **Alternatives**: row-absent-from-base -> fail (no green path: base ref flips at finish; red on empty list); NOTE only (not fail-closed); Claude editing settings.json (rejected: own deny list = user hand edit). +- **Consequences**: CHANGELOG entries land with the user's settings edit (TODO:92). Commit 79f1a3f. diff --git a/.claude/memory/journal.md b/.claude/memory/journal.md index 2d31f42..07c2d06 100644 --- a/.claude/memory/journal.md +++ b/.claude/memory/journal.md @@ -724,3 +724,4 @@ rules: ## 2026-11-12 - 2026-11-12: /feat D4 done on feature/prune-memory-status-reader: 99f10b2 one status classifier for prune-memory (v1+v2), docs bd0687d. 3 challenge rounds (r1 FATAL: memory.sh index reads no status on 4 projects). Gates: floor MET, verifier CONFORME, security PASS (4 LOW). 5 follow-ups in BUGS-FOUND. Merge awaits user. - 2026-11-12: /feat D1+D5+D6 on feature/doctrine-rules-graphify: c69ce9c Session start TODO+digest, web-security deduped, graphify claude install from $REPO; docs a37df2f. 2 challenge rounds (r1 FATAL x2: D5 oracle clash, digest TODO only under ### Actionable -> D1 re-gated, D1b logged). Gates: floor MET, verifier CONFORME, security PASS. Merge awaits user. +- 2026-11-12: /feat dead-deny lock on feature/dead-deny-lock: 79f1a3f push-guard T41 drops dead Write lines, T42 justified list until 3.0.0 (T42c/d/e). 2 challenge rounds (r2 FATAL: base-keyed expiry no green path -> version expiry re-gated). Gates MET/CONFORME/PASS, MEDIUM fail-open fixed. User hand edit of settings.json pending (TODO:92). diff --git a/.claude/memory/learnings.md b/.claude/memory/learnings.md index cfd4c9b..f5c03dc 100644 --- a/.claude/memory/learnings.md +++ b/.claude/memory/learnings.md @@ -2046,3 +2046,9 @@ Rule: when editing a doctrine file under structure locks, grep the test's lock s - **Pattern**: graphifyy 0.9.67 `graphify install` (default platform claude, install.py:691) copies skill into ~/.claude/skills AND appends H1 `# graphify` block at EOF of ~/.claude/CLAUDE.md = CLAUDE.global.md (exact-line marker, curated `## graphify` not matched). `graphify claude install` (install.py:1827) writes ./CLAUDE.md + ./.claude/settings.json (+ .graphify-bak) in cwd, never copies skill. - **Context**: LRN-154 said `graphify install --platform claude` "touches nothing else": wrong. install-plugins.sh ran `graphify claude install` in caller cwd -> polluted foreign project outside trap. Fixed c69ce9c: `(cd "$REPO" && graphify claude install)`. - **Apply**: run `graphify claude install` only from $REPO under guarded-config trap (`make plugin`). Manual recovery `graphify install --platform claude` -> delete trailing `# graphify` EOF hunk, never `git checkout` whole CLAUDE.global.md (loses uncommitted doctrine). Supersedes LRN-154 graphify specifics line. + +## LRN-280 — Expiry keyed on the release base ref has no green path, key it on version.txt (2026-11-12) +- **Pattern**: freshness/expiry check keyed on release base ref (main/origin/main) flips at `gitflow finish`: release prep sees old base, post-merge sees new base -> both states cannot be green. Key expiry on tracked `version.txt` instead (bumped in release/hotfix prep commit). +- **Gotcha**: GNU grep 3.12 `grep -c -f emptyfile` prints nothing (rc 1), not `0`: count comparisons break on empty pattern list. Compare named rows (`grep -vxF -f base list` expected "") so failures name the row. +- **Context**: /feat dead-deny lock 2026-11-12, challenge round 2 FATAL(2) on plan r2 T42e. +- **Apply**: any lock/allowlist with expiry in this repo -> version-keyed, fail-closed on unreadable version. diff --git a/.claude/tasks/TODO.md b/.claude/tasks/TODO.md index 31e0289..20f5b1f 100644 --- a/.claude/tasks/TODO.md +++ b/.claude/tasks/TODO.md @@ -89,7 +89,8 @@ Shared rules for every phase: - [x] **Phase 2, guards** (shipped 2026-11-02 on feature/phase2-guards, merge on user signal: bench `.claude/tasks/plans/2026-11-02-phase2-bench/` (16 ask, 7 deny approved; quoted finish rule, `gitflow_finish*`, `bash -s*` not approved), rtk rc 3 passthrough 60ee4a9, router write guard with a session skill latch 22ff57b + 9bbd1d5, code-limits hook f21e265, locks T62/T63 9887c14, settings 6899a72, release finish in the main loop 536d39e, doctrine 0bf4620, CHANGELOG c3a6977; contract `.claude/tasks/contracts/2026-11-02-phase2-guards-1545.md`) (redesigned 2026-10-25 after a 3-lens challenge, re-challenged the same day: native ask gate, guard hosted in model-router, interpreters in prose, commit-msg hook deferred) - [ ] Phase 2 residuals (stated 2026-11-02): Bash write forms are outside the routing guard (the harness auto-mode "prefer Bash" path); a register.ts reload resets the skill latch; `.claude/worktrees/` writes are code; code-limits state dirs stay in TMPDIR; not caught by a static rule: `… | bash -s`, a sourced `gitflow_finish`, `git -C merge` (soft_deny prose only). - [ ] Phase 2 security gate follow-ups (2026-11-02, non-blocking): MEDIUM `rtk read -n .env` / `rtk read a.txt .env` typed directly pass every static deny (rc 3 → passthrough, no rule) → bench `Bash(rtk read * .env*)`, `Bash(rtk read * */.env*)` + `*/rtk` twins and teach phase2.jq the `* ` shape; LOW code-limits state dir (`mkdir -m 700`, owner check); LOW awk evasions (`system (`, `awk -f`, `gawk`/`mawk`); LOW pre-existing `cat x.key` (no dir prefix) parity gap; doctor.sh:255 jq message should name code-limits and push-guard. MEDIUM rtk read part done 2026-11-06 97c6afc (2 rules, bench R3-R7, LRN-266); the LOWs stay open. - - [ ] User hand edit (phase 2 hand-over): remove the 6 dead deny entries (`Bash(docker run * -v /:*)`, `Bash(git push * :*)`, `Write(**/.git/config)`, `Write(**/.gitconfig)`, `Write(~/.gitconfig)`, `Write(~/.config/git/config)`) and, if wanted, the 6 obsolete `rtk cat|head|tail` forms; lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh T41 (the 4 Write lines) and T42 (base = last release) must be edited alongside. + - [ ] User hand edit (phase 2 hand-over): remove EXACTLY the 6 dead deny entries from settings.json (`Bash(docker run * -v /:*)`, `Bash(git push * :*)`, `Write(**/.git/config)`, `Write(**/.gitconfig)`, `Write(~/.gitconfig)`, `Write(~/.config/git/config)`), nothing else; lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh is prepared by feature/dead-deny-lock (T41 drops the 4 Write lines, T42 forgives only the 2 Bash lines that main carries). Any other removal turns T42 red by design. With that edit, CHANGELOG [Unreleased]: amend :51 gitflow deny bullet ("18 entries" → 14, "Edit/Write of" → "Edit of"; the Write twins never shipped) and add one Fixed bullet (2.0.0 forms `docker run * -v /:*` / `git push * :*` never matched, working forms added ac23cc6, dead ones dropped); :18 "(98 checks)" stale, drop or refresh from a real run. + - [ ] rtk deny forms (user 2026-11-12, split from the line above): the 6 `rtk cat|head|tail *.env*` deny forms (`Bash(rtk cat *.env*)`, `Bash(*/rtk cat *.env*)`, head, tail) said obsolete; removing them needs a verified reason per form and reviewed rows in the push-guard T42 justified list, as its own run. - Killed by the challenges: the phrase-list merge gate; the `$.ui.ask` mod gate (its BDR-068 exception detector was never true: finish runs in the user's reply turn; a hard_deny naming mod sources was the robustness BLOCKER); G2 destructive guard (BLK-022, stays a user-driven task); whole-file code-limit reports (1498 lines > 80 cols across 92 files, over-fires); parsing commit text from Bash; Bash write-form detection in the routing guard (no measured Bash evasion, every inline write was Edit/Write). - Merge gate = native `ask` rules in settings.json, no mod (user pick 2026-10-25; bench r3 G1-G7: all forms DENIED headless incl. `"$HOME"`, absolute path, after `source`; `start` RAN): `Bash(bash */gitflow.sh finish*)`, `Bash(gitflow_finish*)`, `Bash(git merge *)`; evaluate in the same bench `Bash(git pull *)` and `git push x:develop` forms before adding them. Trade-off accepted: the BDR-068 /close auto-finish gets one dialog click (ask beats allow, no exemption); release-executor finish prompts too (its dispatcher runs finish inline if a sub-agent cannot prompt, BLK-018 option b). hard_deny line: "never edit `permissions.ask` to skip the gate". - Routing guard (user pick: "always through a skill") hosted in `mods/model-router` (owner of the only run signal; mod state is plugin-private, `runMain` is BEST-tier-only and never ends: wrong signal). `tool.call` on Edit/Write/NotebookEdit of a code file by the MAIN loop (no `agentId`) → deny with reason "route through /hotfix (≤2 files, obvious), /feat, /bugfix or /ship-feature" UNLESS this turn's `turnMain.source ∈ {skill, model}` or a `/route` sticky is in force (explicit escape hatch). Free: docs (.md), `.claude/**`, sub-agents, any write inside a skill run. Bash write forms deferred until a measured evasion. hard_deny gains "a guard redirect is not a refusal to route around: enter the skill". Doctrine: the ceiling bullet becomes "the main loop writes no code outside a skill run, whatever the model". Proof: routing bench cases (L3 must enter a skill), long-brief replay in a clone, false-deny fixtures (doc edits, executor edits, in-skill edits), guard-off = today. diff --git a/.claude/tasks/contracts/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md b/.claude/tasks/contracts/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..869aaac --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/tasks/contracts/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md @@ -0,0 +1,36 @@ +# CONTRACT — dead-deny-lock +- date: 2026-11-12 | flow: feat | branch: feature/dead-deny-lock +- status: active + +## REQUEST (verbatim — IMMUTABLE) +Dead deny entries, test half (user decision 2026-11-12 [gated]: Claude edits the test, the user removes the 6 lines from settings.json by hand and commits). TODO.md:156 + :92: the 6 dead deny entries `Bash(docker run * -v /:*)`, `Bash(git push * :*)`, `Write(**/.git/config)`, `Write(**/.gitconfig)`, `Write(~/.gitconfig)`, `Write(~/.config/git/config)` (working forms `-v /:/*`, ` :**`, `Edit(...)` added 2026-10-23, LRN in journal:646: `Write(glob)` deny never blocks the Write tool, `Edit(...)` does; mixed `* :*` / `* -v /:*` forms never match) are kept by lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh T41 (requires the 4 Write lines) and T42 (nothing removed vs the last release on main). Change only lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh: T41 stops requiring the 4 `Write(...)` lines (Edit forms stay required); T42 accepts exactly these 6 removals through a justified-removal list (each with its reason), anything else removed still fails. The test must be green both before and after the user's settings.json edit. Do not touch settings.json. make test needs GATES_TIMEOUT=600 + PATH=$HOME/.bun/bin:$PATH (LRN-271). Foreign-code style. In force: BDR-100, LRN-275, LRN-277. + +## CLARIFICATIONS +Q: plan? / A: .claude/tasks/plans/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md, latest revision is binding (orchestrator) +Q: who edits settings.json? / A: the user, by hand, after this run merges (user, 2026-11-12) [gated] +Q: justified list content? / A: only the 2 Bash entries main carries; the 4 Write lines leave T41 with a reason comment (base has no Write entry; a stale row fails, see below) (orchestrator, round 1) +Q: list row absent from base? / A: FAIL (T42e) (user, 2026-11-12, superseded: no green path, challenge round 2) +Q: stale list policy, re-gate? / A: expiry by version: `removed_ok_until=3.0.0`; T42e fails once version.txt is past it while the list is non-empty; the list is emptied in that bump (user, 2026-11-12) [gated] +Q: rtk cat|head|tail forms? / A: separate TODO item with its own reviewed rows; TODO.md:92 rewritten to exactly the 6 (user, 2026-11-12) [gated] +Q: baseline fact / A: main and origin/main (2026-11-06) hold only the 2 Bash entries; the 4 Write lines are guarded by T41 alone (orchestrator, read-only check) + +## ACCEPTANCE CRITERIA +1. push-guard suite green on the current settings.json. + CHECK: cd /home/bchanot/Documents/claude && GATES_TIMEOUT=600 PATH="$HOME/.bun/bin:$PATH" make test suite=lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh 2>&1 | grep -q "^PASS=[0-9]* FAIL=0" && echo PG-NOW + EXPECT: PG-NOW + EVIDENCE: MET exit=0 marker-found :: PG-NOW +2. The suite proves the after-state in-suite: the lock bites (T42c), the user's 6-line edit is forgiven (T42d), the list expires by version (T42e); 3 more passing checks. + CHECK: cd /home/bchanot/Documents/claude && P=lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh && grep -q 'T42c-lock-bites' $P && grep -q 'T42d-edit-forgiven' $P && grep -q 'T42e-list-not-expired' $P && grep -q '^removed_ok_until=3.0.0$' $P && GATES_TIMEOUT=600 PATH="$HOME/.bun/bin:$PATH" make test suite=$P 2>&1 | grep -q '^PASS=133 FAIL=0' && echo PG-AFTER + EXPECT: PG-AFTER + EVIDENCE: MET exit=0 marker-found :: PG-AFTER +3. T41 no longer requires the 4 Write lines, requires the 2 working Bash forms; Edit forms still required; the justified list holds exactly the 2 Bash entries, each with a reason line. + CHECK: cd /home/bchanot/Documents/claude && P=lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh && ! grep -q '^Write(' $P && grep -qx 'Edit(\*\*/.git/config)' $P && grep -qx 'Edit(~/.config/git/config)' $P && grep -qxF 'Bash(docker run * -v /:/*)' $P && grep -qxF 'Bash(git push * :**)' $P && grep -qxF 'Bash(git push * :*)' $P && grep -qxF 'Bash(docker run * -v /:*)' $P && [ "$(grep -c '^# mixed .* form never matches' $P)" = 2 ] && ! grep -q $'\t' $P && echo T41-OK + EXPECT: T41-OK + EVIDENCE: MET exit=0 marker-found :: T41-OK +4. Full suite green, shellcheck clean. + CHECK: cd /home/bchanot/Documents/claude && shellcheck -S warning lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh && GATES_TIMEOUT=600 PATH="$HOME/.bun/bin:$PATH" make test 2>&1 | tail -1 | grep -q 'all suites green' && echo GREEN + EXPECT: GREEN + EVIDENCE: MET exit=0 marker-found :: GREEN + +## FILE SCOPE +lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh diff --git a/.claude/tasks/plans/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md b/.claude/tasks/plans/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..7db8796 --- /dev/null +++ b/.claude/tasks/plans/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md @@ -0,0 +1,117 @@ +# PLAN r3 — dead deny lock (test half), /feat 2026-11-12 + +Contract: .claude/tasks/contracts/2026-11-12-dead-deny-lock-1239.md +Branch: feature/dead-deny-lock (off develop 1226d05) +File: lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh only. settings.json is NOT touched (user hand edit after merge). +Style: foreign code, keep the file's inline style (`check`, heredoc lists, small helpers like +`has_deny`/`rv` already exist); lines ≤ 80 chars; `set -u`, no `-e`, no pipefail. + +## Facts (read-only) +- push-guard.test.sh:300-322 T41 heredoc list of required deny entries incl. 4 `Write(...)` + 4 `Edit(...)`. +- :324-348 T42: base = fresher of origin/main / main; `lost` = base deny entries absent from + `$S` (settings.json); `check T42-nothing-removed "$lost" ""`. +- main and origin/main (2026-11-06) hold `Bash(docker run * -v /:*)` and `Bash(git push * :*)`, not the + 4 Write lines nor the working forms `Bash(docker run * -v /:/*)`, `Bash(git push * :**)`. +- Current suite: PASS=130 FAIL=0, "T42 base: origin/main". +- `$WORK` is a mktemp dir removed by the EXIT trap. + +## r2 changes (challenge round 1: correctness CONCERNS(1), robustness CONCERNS(2), simplicity SOLID) +- Base (main) has no `Write(` deny entry at all: the justified list holds only the 2 Bash entries main + carries; the 4 Write lines just leave T41 (reason in a comment). User 2026-11-12 [gated]: a list row + absent from base FAILS (T42e), so the list is emptied in the release commit that ships the removal; + listing the Write lines would turn red at once. +- In-suite positive proof T42d (settings minus the list → nothing lost) replaces the out-of-`make test` + worktree CHECK (auto-mode hard_deny shape, BLK-040) (robustness 2, correctness 2). +- Working forms `-v /:/*` and ` :**` go into the T41 heredoc, unconditional (all three lenses). +- List = one heredoc, reason as a `#` comment line above each entry, flush-left; `grep -v '^#'` keeps the + entries (no tab, no temp .tsv) (simplicity 2, robustness 3, correctness 4). +- `deny_lost` at top level after `rv()`; the stale T42 comment rewritten once (simplicity 3-4). +- TODO.md:92 rewritten to "exactly the 6"; rtk forms split into their own item (user 2026-11-12 [gated]). + +## r3 changes (challenge round 2: robustness FATAL(2), correctness CONCERNS(2), simplicity CONCERNS(1)) +- T42e "row absent from base → fail" had no green path (release prep: base still has the rows; after + finish: stale) and stayed red on an empty list (`grep -c -f empty` prints nothing). User re-gate + 2026-11-12 [gated]: expiry by version. One variable `removed_ok_until=3.0.0` (the release that ships the + removal); T42e fails once version.txt is past it while the list is non-empty, naming the rows. Green at + every step: prep 3.0.0 (equal), main/develop after finish (equal), next bump (hotfix or release) red + until the list is emptied in that bump, where main no longer carries the rows. +- T42d simulates the user's real edit: `$S` minus the 6 literal entries, then `deny_lost` must be empty + (an empty or wrong list now fails T42d) (simplicity r2-1). +- AC3 asserts no line starting `Write(` in the file (all 4 gone from T41) (correctness r2-2, robustness r2-3). +- One forgive-rule comment (list header); the has_deny comment keeps only the Write-twin reason and why T41 + holds the working forms; T42 comment unchanged except one clause (simplicity r2-3). +- Line refs corrected: has_deny :301, T41 heredoc :305-324, T42 comment :327-328; the jq filter may be + split across lines inside its quotes to stay ≤ 80 chars. + +## PLAN + [ ] T41 heredoc (:305-324) — delete the 4 lines `Write(**/.git/config)`, `Write(**/.gitconfig)`, + `Write(~/.gitconfig)`, `Write(~/.config/git/config)`; append 2 lines `Bash(docker run * -v /:/*)` + and `Bash(git push * :**)`. Keep everything else. Above `has_deny()` (:301) add 2 comment lines: + "# Write twins of the 4 Edit lines dropped 2026-11-12: a Write(glob) deny never + # blocks the Write tool, the Edit form does. The 2 Bash lines guard the working forms." + [ ] Right after `check T41-new-deny-present …`, top level, the justified list (heredoc body flush-left, + no leading spaces; the indentation here is the plan's layout only): + # Deny entries of the last release dropped on purpose, forgiven by T42 until + # version.txt passes removed_ok_until (T42e): empty the list in that bump. + removed_ok_until=3.0.0 + grep -v '^#' > "$WORK/removed-ok" <<'EOF' + # mixed `* -v /:*` form never matches; `-v /:/*` kept (2026-10-23) + Bash(docker run * -v /:*) + # mixed `* :*` form never matches; ` :**` kept (2026-10-23) + Bash(git push * :*) + EOF + [ ] T42e right after the list, top level (no base needed): + cur=$(tr -d '[:space:]' < "$ROOT/version.txt") + expired="" + if [ -s "$WORK/removed-ok" ] && [ "$cur" != "$removed_ok_until" ] && + [ "$(printf '%s\n' "$removed_ok_until" "$cur" | sort -V | tail -1)" = "$cur" ]; then + expired=$(tr '\n' ' ' < "$WORK/removed-ok"); fi + check T42e-list-not-expired "$expired" "" + [ ] T42 comment (:327-328): append ", except the justified list above" after "is still there"; rest + verbatim. + [ ] Top level, right after `rv() { … }`, add: + deny_lost() { # → base deny entries missing from it, minus the list + git -C "$ROOT" show "$base:settings.json" 2>/dev/null \ + | jq -r --slurpfile now "$1" '' \ + | grep -vxF -f "$WORK/removed-ok" + } + In the else branch replace the `lost=$(…)` pipeline with `lost=$(deny_lost "$S")`; + `check T42-nothing-removed "$lost" ""` unchanged. + [ ] In the else branch, after T42-nothing-removed (each line ≤ 80 chars): + T42c (lock still bites): + probe=$(printf '%s\n' "$basedeny" | grep -vxF -f "$WORK/removed-ok" | head -1) + jq --arg e "$probe" '.permissions.deny -= [$e]' "$S" > "$WORK/s-probe.json" + check T42c-lock-bites \ + "$(deny_lost "$WORK/s-probe.json" | grep -cxF -- "$probe")" 1 + T42d (the user's hand edit, TODO.md:92, simulated): + jq '.permissions.deny -= ["Bash(docker run * -v /:*)", + "Bash(git push * :*)", "Write(**/.git/config)", "Write(**/.gitconfig)", + "Write(~/.gitconfig)", "Write(~/.config/git/config)"]' "$S" > "$WORK/s-after.json" + check T42d-edit-forgiven "$(deny_lost "$WORK/s-after.json")" "" + (no line of the jq array may START with `Write(`: keep a quote or spaces before each entry.) + +## Edge cases +- Before the user's edit: T41, T42, T42c, T42d, T42e green (version 2.0.0 < 3.0.0). +- After the user's edit of exactly the 6: T41 green (no Write required), T42 forgives the 2 Bash rows, + T42d green. Any other removal → T42 red. +- Release 3.0.0 prep (version.txt = 3.0.0, base = old main with the rows): T42 forgives, T42e equal → + green. After finish (base = 3.0.0 main without the rows): nothing lost, T42e equal → green on main, + develop, any hotfix branch before its bump. +- Next bump (3.0.1 hotfix or 3.1.0 release prep): T42e red naming the 2 rows until the list is emptied in + that bump; emptying is safe because main no longer carries them. Empty list → T42e green. +- If the user's edit has not landed by then: emptying the list while the rows are still present is + harmless (nothing lost); removing them later needs a new row stamped with the next version. +- `grep -vxF` exits 1 on no output: fine under `set -u` without `-e`/pipefail. A missing removed-ok + file makes T42c fail (fail closed). +- SKIP path (no main ref): T41 and T42e still run; T42/T42c/T42d skipped. +- Expected count on this repo (base origin/main): PASS=133 FAIL=0 (130 + T42c + T42d + T42e). + +## Tests +- The suite itself (T41 edited, T42 via deny_lost, T42c/T42d/T42e new), run only through `make test`. + +## Disposition +- honors BDR-111 / T41-T42 non-weakening lock: still fails on any unlisted removal (T42c proves it). +- honors BDR-100: the citers of the 6 entries are TODO.md:92/:156 (closed at capitalize after the user's + edit) and this test; journal:646 history untouched. +- user decision 2026-11-12 [gated]: settings.json untouched here. +- LRN-275 explicit staging; LRN-277 no stdin readers in the brief. From 86d4ff9167c38b796bf40407bdd717537a6d5303 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: bchanot Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 14:30:30 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 3/4] chore(audits): log dead-deny lock follow-ups --- .claude/audits/BUGS-FOUND.md | 6 ++++++ 1 file changed, 6 insertions(+) diff --git a/.claude/audits/BUGS-FOUND.md b/.claude/audits/BUGS-FOUND.md index 4e3c2b1..745c996 100644 --- a/.claude/audits/BUGS-FOUND.md +++ b/.claude/audits/BUGS-FOUND.md @@ -44,3 +44,9 @@ - Stale graphify claims outside the D6 scope: .gitignore:54-56 ("written into the repo by `graphify claude install`"), plugins.lock.json:37 (bare `graphify install && graphify claude install` recipe), update-all.sh:310-312 (re-run `graphify claude install` MANUALLY, no trap, cwd-dependent → point at `make plugin`), install-plugins.sh:688/690/1269 labels ("dependencies", "Claude Code integration", "PreToolUse hook" for steps the trap reverts), install-plugins.sh:694-695 LRN-071 comment now gates only `graphify install`, guard comment vs rule duplication. LRN-154 (learnings.md:1381) still says `graphify install --platform claude` "touches nothing else". Severity: low. Discovered while: /feat D6 challenge + gates. Not fixed. - lib/tests/curated-config-guard.test.sh does not lock the Step 7 `(cd "$REPO" && graphify claude install)` subshell; a later edit dropping it passes make test. Severity: low. Discovered while: /feat D6 challenge round 2. Not fixed. - install-plugins.sh Step 7 hook window (pre-existing): `graphify claude install` hooks sit live in $REPO/.claude/settings.json until the EXIT trap; a SIGKILL skips the trap. Severity: low. Discovered while: /feat D6 security gate. Not fixed. + + +- lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh T42c — passes even if the `$WORK/s-probe.json` jq write fails (empty slurp makes every base entry look lost); weakens what T42c proves, not the lock. Severity: low. Discovered while: /feat dead-deny security gate. Not fixed. +- lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh deny_lost — no pipefail: a missing list file or jq failure empties `lost` (T42 green); mitigated by T42c (red) and T40. Severity: low. Discovered while: /feat dead-deny security gate. Not fixed. +- Dead-entry premise (Write(glob) deny never blocks Write; mixed `* :*` / `* -v /:*` forms never match) rests on one live probe 2026-10-23 (journal); nothing re-proves it if Claude Code permission semantics change. Severity: low. Discovered while: /feat dead-deny security gate. Not fixed. +- lib/tests/push-guard.test.sh:421-424 T62F (pre-existing) — `mktemp` settings copy outside `$WORK`, removed only on the normal path (no trap). Severity: low. Discovered while: /feat dead-deny security gate. Not fixed. From 12c3534be07d130ef8b94d41a92b5077e6da1baa Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: bchanot Date: Thu, 12 Nov 2026 15:17:32 +0100 Subject: [PATCH 4/4] chore(settings): drop the 6 dead deny entries --- settings.json | 8 +------- 1 file changed, 1 insertion(+), 7 deletions(-) diff --git a/settings.json b/settings.json index c994fe9..77fda30 100644 --- a/settings.json +++ b/settings.json @@ -285,14 +285,12 @@ "Bash(docker run --privileged*)", "Bash(docker run * --privileged*)", "Bash(docker * /var/run/docker.sock*)", - "Bash(docker run -v /:*)", - "Bash(docker run * -v /:*)", "Bash(docker run * -v /:/*)", + "Bash(docker run -v /:*)", "Bash(git push --delete *)", "Bash(git push * --delete *)", "Bash(git push --mirror*)", "Bash(git push * --mirror*)", - "Bash(git push * :*)", "Bash(git push * :**)", "Bash(git push --force-with-lease*)", "Bash(git push * --force-with-lease*)", @@ -352,13 +350,9 @@ "Bash(* GIT_CONFIG_GLOBAL=*)", "Bash(* GIT_CONFIG_SYSTEM=*)", "Edit(**/.git/config)", - "Write(**/.git/config)", "Edit(**/.gitconfig)", - "Write(**/.gitconfig)", "Edit(~/.gitconfig)", - "Write(~/.gitconfig)", "Edit(~/.config/git/config)", - "Write(~/.config/git/config)", "Bash(awk *system(*)", "Bash(head * .env*)", "Bash(tail * .env*)",